Embracing Marketing Mistakes
Embracing Marketing Mistakes is the show that teaches you growth from failure.
Every week, the Founder of Prohibition PR, Chris Norton and his co-host, Will Ockenden, sit down with the people behind some of marketing's best-known brands and ask the question most interviews avoid: what went wrong, and what did you do next?
Rand Fishkin, Richard Shotton, Ben Branson, Phil Barden and Roger Dooley have all owned up. So have marketers from Yorkshire Tea, Lexus, Adobe, Deliveroo and Ogilvy.
You hear about the campaigns that flopped and the calls they got wrong, told honestly and with a sense of humour. Then you get the lesson, so you can skip the expensive part.
A top 10 UK marketing podcast on Apple, with 135+ interviews and 550,000 downloads across 172 countries. New episode every week.
If you have a story to tell and would like to appear on the show, tell us your biggest marketing mistake and drop us a line.
Embracing Marketing Mistakes
EP 4: Will ChatGPT or Gemini Transform Marketing Departments or Threaten Their Future? - Andrew Bruce Smith
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Join us as we unpack the endless possibilities of AI in marketing with the extraordinary Andrew Bruce Smith, Chair of CIPR AI in PR panel and co-wrote the CIPRs guide to ethics in AI. From his humble beginnings as a journalist in the mid-80s to his current role as a trainer and consultant, Andrew shares priceless insights from his professional journey that will reshape your understanding of AI.
Andrew's expert insights into AI and its role in major tech giants like Google and Facebook are mind-opening. We tackle the intriguing question: Could AI become sentient? And if it does, what are the implications? Andrew doesn’t shy away from addressing the ethical considerations inherent in AI development. From the potential of AI in PR to the conundrum of choosing the right AI tool, we leave no stone unturned. Amid the discussions, we also touch on Microsoft's AI co-pilot and the implications of its pricing.
In the final part of our conversation, we delve into the serious implications of AI on creativity, copyright, and the increasing necessity for AI regulation. In an era where AI has the potential to become exponentially more intelligent, we examine how this can disrupt our traditional understanding of these important issues. Drawing on the wisdom of renowned figures, we explore the profound impact of AI on our future.
And of course, no conversation is complete without a dash of humor, as Andrew recalls a near-mishap at a press conference, linking it to the art of getting attention in the age of AI. Tune in for an entertaining, insightful, and thought-provoking exploration of AI's impact on marketing and beyond.
Do you have a F*ck up to share?
Your competitors are being named by AI. Are you? One of our clients went from being named in 4 of 50 buyer prompts to 19 in 90 days. Book your free AI visibility check with Chris here. 👉 [Book free AI Visibility Check] 👈
Subscribe to our newsletter
The mistakes we see marketers make, every fortnight. 👉 [Subscribe here] 👈
Follow Chris:
X, TikTok, LinkedIn
Follow Will:
LinkedIn
Follow The Show:
TikTok, YouTube
AI in Marketing
Andrew Bruce SmithWhen people say what's the one tool that you would use, well, I guess it would be ChatGPT or, strictly speaking, chatgpt plus.
Chris NortonWhen we get to ChatGPT 10, right? Is that a case of like the alien and Star Trek movies, where you go computer, tell me you know and it'll do calculations and every, and it is more intelligent than the human race? Is that where we're heading?
Will OckendenAnd to add to that, should we be afraid Andrew, That'd be very afraid. We've all seen terminated to. Should we be afraid? There's nothing wrong?
Chris Nortonwith a bit of fear. Somebody out there working in a marketing agency. Should they be worried? Is it? Are the jobs going to go avert of all? What do you think? What's your take on it?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, I kind of agree with Sam Altman of OpenAI. I mean, this is his line, which he's been touting for some time, which is that the AI should be replacing tasks, but not jobs.
Vicki MurphyWelcome to socially unacceptable from f**kups to fame, the marketing podcast that celebrates the professional mishaps, mistakes and misjudgments, while delivering valuable marketing and life lessons in the time it takes you to eat your lunch.
Chris NortonSo welcome aboard episode four. Thank you very much for joining us. We really appreciate it. In today's podcast, we're tackling what is probably one of the most talked about topics in marketing artificial intelligence and not just marketing in business in general, it's all over the media and to do this we're looking enough to be joined by one of our favorite and foremost experts in this area, Mr Andrew Bruce Smith. Good morning, Good afternoon. Sorry, Andrew, how?
Andrew Bruce Smithare you Good afternoon? I'm very well, thank you. Thanks for having me.
Chris NortonIt's okay. We won't talk about the massive technical f**kup that we've had at the beginning of the show. The show is about f**kups, but we'll move on. I'll just give a little bit of a brief overview of you. Andrew is a renowned expert in artificial intelligence and its application in communication, social media, seo and analytics. Over the years, he's strategically which is a hard word to say integrated AI into digital comms programs for one of the world's largest brands, which I'm sure you'll want to talk about. In 2018, the CIPR hailed him as one of the greatest PR thinkers. And how's that for an accolade, andrew? Ooh, sir, I could possibly comment.
Chris NortonDoes that give you an inferiority complex?
Will OckendenWell, it does a little bit. Yeah, if I'm honest.
Chris NortonCurrently, andrew provides training and consultation in AI, integrated social media analytics, seo and digital marketing for the CIPR, the media trust, the Incorporated Society of British Advertisers Understanding Modern Government and the SMI Group. He also co-wrote the CIPR's Guide to Ethics in AI, which I have written, written, read, which I have read. Well, I did that, which I've read. I did not write it. F**kup number two.
Will OckendenOh dear. Well, that is certainly an impressive biography. I need to start working on my own, I think. Actually, Coincidentally, Andrew and I actually spoke at the same conference a few weeks ago in London, talking about social media marketing and AI in higher education, so I'm quite keen to kind of dig into some of the themes we discussed there too. So welcome to the show, Andrew. Have we missed anything there with your rather extensive biography?
Andrew Bruce SmithNo, that's fine. That's enough about me. That's enough about me.
Chris NortonIt's not actually that I'm quite interested to hear a bit about you, andrew, because we've known each other for quite a while. You've done quite. We've had you a couple of training days and I've attended quite a few. We've attended similar things. We both spoke at the CIPR's event years ago because I believe you were a co-author of Share this too, like I was. You wrote the bit on analytics. Is that right?
Andrew Bruce SmithThat's right. I had two chapters Green green me One on analytics and one about network analysis. That was 10 years ago about the power of networks and using AI and data and all that good stuff, so I've been boring on about it for a very long time.
Chris NortonSo just walk me through, because you were a journalist when you started, weren't you?
Andrew Bruce SmithThis is true. I can't quite believe it myself, but my career began in 1985. That's nearly 38 years ago. Omg, yes, I did. I started as a journalist writing for a very, very auspicious trade magazine, the retail news agent tobaccoist and confectioner, or sweetie and fag weekly as it was known. So that's, then, my humble beginnings as an editorial assistant on said title. Absolutely, and let's be honest, when I started my career as a journalist, the acronym PR, I thought, stood for Proportional Representation. I had absolutely no idea that this whole industry existed, allegedly to make my life as a journalist that much easier. My most useful piece of technology, I have to admit, back in the mid-80s, was a metal spike that you put all the press releases on. That you thought rubbish. So every morning you get like 200 press releases in the post and then I get 198 of them and plonk them on the spike because they weren't very good.
Chris NortonThey were probably in from us, to be fair.
Andrew Bruce SmithNo, not back in the day, but Not in the mid-80s, though, no, no, I wasn't around then, exactly.
Chris NortonMid-80s. Is that how long ago back it goes? You do, mate. You look like a With you know you've got the best beard in public relations.
Andrew Bruce SmithI'd say Well, it's got, great it. And you're like yeah, I got my OAP bus pass a few weeks ago because I turned 60. So there you go.
Chris NortonMate, you don't look 60,. Trust me, you got the check.
Andrew Bruce SmithThank you very much. Yeah, I'll tell you.
Will OckendenSo from journalist to AI, then, so talk to us about that.
Andrew Bruce SmithOkay. So if I've been in 38 years of journalism, pr, whatever, I like to say that I've had an interest in AI for 42 years because I started university in 1981 studying English literature and philosophy. I was a classic arts graduate but out of mate who was doing computer science and he gave me this book. It's called Girdle Escher Bach. It was written in 1979 by a guy called Duggish Hostader. It's still today regarded as the Bible of artificial intelligence. It won a Pulitzer Prize and I have to confess I read it and it blew my mind back then and I've had a lot of that lifelong interest in AI ever since. And in fact when I moved into working in PR late 1980s, I was working for a tech PR firm. One of the clients was a software company called Ball International, famous at the time, and they had a programming tool called Prolog which was one of the very, very, very early AI programming tools and I thought this is brilliant. I'm going to start creating AI's in the late 80s.
Andrew Bruce SmithOf course I didn't. A, because I can't program for toffee and B, of course it wasn't fit for purpose. So I mean AI is a term I think originally got coined in the late 50s. John McCarthy is a famous conference where that was bandied around then and every decade since there's always been a kind of a a peak in hype of interest in AI and it all fell away. So this term AI winter gets, gets gets used quite a lot the idea that it's going to, it's going to do stuff, and then, of course, it never did. Of course this time it kind of is, is it is different, but yes, I've always had that interest in AI specifically and also just technology generally and specifically technology in its application to Pio and cons. I've bored people rigid for for best part of 30 years Cause I was allegedly the second person in Britain to send the press release by email. That was 33 years ago and I yeah, yeah, yeah, 33 years ago 1990.
Andrew Bruce SmithAnd there were about five journalists who had email addresses, one of whom was the late great Jack Schofield, who was the tech editor at the Guardian for for a very, very long time. Yeah, and then, and Jack, completely unprompt. So of course people say, well, you were second. Well, who was first? And it's Frank.
Chris NortonFrank Amani Good, good good job of mine.
Andrew Bruce SmithNow he was the PR manager for Apple UK in 1990. So he beat me by about 10 days. So he sent the first one and I sent the second one to Jack Schofield and three or four other tech journalists who had email addresses at the time. And then Jack Schofield, completely unprompt, about a month later, wrote this piece saying that Frank and I were pioneering this new approach of sending press releases electronically. And it's like wow, wow, yeah, see, he regressed writing, that of course years later.
Andrew Bruce SmithBut yeah, yeah. So it was Jackie Jack Schofield that tipped me off to this crazy thing called the Worldwide Web in 1994. And you know, it took a bit of technical competence to be able to figure out how to actually download the software and lots of other gobbins, and wrote a couple of lines of HTML and thought, hmm, there's something in this, this is the information super highway. There you go, absolutely. Those are the days.
Will OckendenSo what's? What's changed with a I? So there's been various I winters over the years. You've you've kind of had a continued interest in it. Why now is it reach tipping point?
Andrew Bruce SmithWhy did I have gosh? How do you go? I mean, is this the color reasons? I mean, first of all, it quite quite simply computing power and the application of certain techniques.
Andrew Bruce SmithWe've all heard the concept of, we've heard the term machine learning, which again is not exactly new, but what happened with available until I guess the last ten, fifteen years, was the computing power and the data to actually do that kind of or apply that kind of process in anger, when you look at some of the use of a I, for example content generation, which will get onto this in detail in a minute. But you go about ten years you had tools like wordsmiths, which you know early tool for using a I to help create content. You know the associate press began using that about ten years ago, using ever since They've probably turned out hundreds of thousands, possibly approaching millions, of articles using a I. And who's noticed? Probably nobody that.
Andrew Bruce SmithThat's not new, but it's really a combination of the compute power. I guess the expertise in a I research just and it's still, admittedly a tiny, tiny number of people Really do have that actual kind of genuine I expertise and competence. But also does the techniques have you where your large language models, for example, are all using a technique developed by google, the transformer technology, which their research is effectively gave away for free In twenty eighteen and opening a line, everybody else went oh, thanks very much, will have that.
Chris NortonThe tea, that's the tea, isn't it?
Andrew Bruce Smiththat's the tea of gbt. Yet generalized preform transform, it's about two lines of code. I mean it's it's crazy to think that the relatively tiny amount of computer code, form, the basis, is quite Revolutionary approach to language models and content generation etc. So to answer that question, it's a combination of factors. Said it's not as though it's for the sky last November, I think to most people on the planet it kind of feels like suddenly it's here.
Andrew Bruce SmithThis has been a long time coming and again developments like the trans, the transformer approach in twenty eighteen, that's had a big effect. Again, who would have thought that that's treating language as a statistical and probabilistic distribution problem Was the way forward, whereas decades before you are trying to. How do we build machines that basically think like us? We're trying to get a mirror, the human brain, and you know progress was very, very, very slow and then suddenly go, well, this is treated like this and it's like, oh, who knew? Who knew that can be an unbelievably effective way of getting a machine to basically generate, in this case the text and language that we can find quite useful.
Chris NortonBut suppose right. So what will? I been
The Impact of AI on Marketing
Chris Nortontalking about this? I've read various things on a. I massively into it. The thing about it is you apparently say that you don't think I is that intelligent yet, whereas I would disagree with that slightly from what? From what I have heard. So I get your point because I is generative. The generative I outside of it, guess, is the words based on trillions and trillions of documents and letters and and things online that it's read up to September twenty twenty one, I believe and then it predicts what the next word should be in a, using its neural networks to predict what the what the next word should should go in front of the next word, and it produces amazing content. The generative stuff, which is the thing that's made it look really, really clever, but really it's like gambling or guessing, is guessing its way through some content once you give me a prompt.
Andrew Bruce SmithIf you want to be pedantic, what it does is it takes. It takes the words, the words and letters, paragraphs you input into it. Brakes to the so called tokens, but a jargon that people in front of the. So the open. I have a little free tool that says put the text in and will show you the tokens we get, we create. So that could be a single word, it could be a single letter, it could be a part of the word. All those tokens, those parts, words, whatever, get converted into numbers. So underlying all, it's simply analyzing numbers and statistical relationships between integers, between numbers, and then those get output, reconverted back into the symbols that we then read and then we interpret it and I can't even say I mean I made reference to the book, your lesson bar, don't push off starter.
Andrew Bruce SmithI have every now and again he's, he said of, pops up because people into him saying you know, you're the, you're the sort of the grandfather, if you will, of a I. What do you think? And consistently for the last forty odd years, he said Well, you know this idea of a I becoming sentient. This is not never gonna happen in my lifetime. And they're rather alarmingly. I think it was last week he was interviewed by the new york times and he's gone. Oh yeah, I'm not quite sure anymore now. He's not saying it's, it's gonna get sent in tomorrow or next year. But he and clearly others like jeff hinson from google and sundry other people, are clearly revising their opinion about how quickly that may get to us. Now I'm saying, as I say, it's been two or three years time. But certainly their view was, you know, it's not happening hundreds of years and now it's kind of like well, you know what, maybe it's possible. It's not as unlikely as they thought it was, even a few years ago.
Chris NortonSo five or six developers of left at the department of google and I've been doing that, the tours because they're worried that it's not being done ethically incorrect and I've listened to some of the podcast and interviews and read some of the articles that they've written about and they're saying that If you think that chat three, chat gpt three point five was good, chat from gpt four, to keep saying that and was ten is ten times more intelligent than three point five and in already is intelligent as albert einstein, that is in the space of six months, so where is it gonna be in the space of three years? That's the bit that is, I think people, where you start to go and I'm in it, and that's why people have started walking from google saying this isn't being done for ethical purposes, this is being created For for monetary benefit, because if we don't do it and to add to that, face book this week met us or a matter that's usually has launched its version now, as well as a net- what was the whole bunch of things to say about that?
Andrew Bruce SmithI mean, first of all, I agree it's disturbing literally every single one of the big tech firms. Since the turn of the year I've either completely removed or at least that drastically downgraded their internal a I ethics teams. Yeah, microsoft had about team of fifty people. Is that I'd like two people in the dog? I'm it post. I don't think I'd very good signal to the world that says you know what? We've gone back to this idea of ask for forgiveness, not not permission. Yeah, I'll give you google have acted very responsibly to date because in a way, they've they've led the way in in a I for for for a very, very long time.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, in principle, they themselves could have released a chat gpt type products couple years ago. They chose not to because they said look, this is powerful stuff. You know, we wanna be responsible about this and we wanna make sure we got the guard roles where else in place. That Open I, I release chat gpt and, as I understand it, actually virtually everyone open. I didn't really wanna put it out there, not because they thought it's gonna, it's gonna be sentient. But they did. It's really good. But allegedly sam cio overrode them said nasty, yeah. So they had no idea about how the world respond to the release of chat gpt into the world, but clearly it's taken off like while far Google, it would seem, sitting there going crap.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, I'm quick, quick get barred out, get barred out let's get the ethics guys in and let's tell them that their services are no longer required, because, well, when push comes to show, it's a race, it's now effectively become a race, and it's an arms race.
Chris Nortonit's an a arms race, isn't it?
Chris NortonCorrect yes, that's how it feels when I say okay, my question for you, then I'm doing first one. So for marketing people, and it becomes people marketing people using this. Which is better? Because I've got questions for you from both chat, gpt and barred and you can decide which is the better interviewer Of the two. If you had to go to date with which what? Which one's which one's more, which one's more intelligent sorry, I don't know if that's come out right which one's more intelligent, would you say? I'm more useful to marketing people?
Andrew Bruce SmithOkay, so just just to make things complicated, of course, patently it depends on what kind of day looking for. You know, I'm a consultant. So it depends why restricts it to just gpt versus barred white wine on? Throw clawed into the mix. You know, clawed to came out to last week for the first time. Claude to is freely available to anyone who wants to try it out. If it's just between gpt and barred then I have to say I'm on almost kind of criteria. Then gpt does seem to be superior to barred.
Chris NortonBut but barred updated two weeks ago, isn't? It was like last couple of weeks where gpt's out of date yeah, they're all being refined.
Andrew Bruce SmithI mean, well, a couple of things. If you you take chat, gpt plus, which has all the various plugins, the release of the code interpreter, plug in what rather it was announced in march, but now everyone who's paying the twenty bucks a month Can get the code interpreter, I mean that I do think is genuinely kind of mind blowing. And you give a spreadsheet of data you don't even tell it is, it works it out and then it analyzes it for you. It's like having a pretty decent data analyst on tap. Twenty four seven. I mean just just some sort of simple things that the experiment you with. I said, look, there you go, there's a data set, and it analyzes it and I said, is everything in that data set you think my interest a journalist? And it says, sure, here you go, here's some, some suggestions, and you can just keep having that conversation with it and eventually get to the point where you go what can you just draft a pressure lease based upon the insights that you've gained from that data. I took about four minutes.
Will OckendenSo on that, Andrew, actually I'm keen to take a bit of a step back. As marketers, then, should we be interested? Should we care about AI? There's an awful lot of talk about it, but I'm also aware as marketers we exist in a bit of a bubble. So should we be using it and, if so, how should we be using it?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, your short answer is yes, in my humble opinion.
AI Applications in PR and Marketing
Andrew Bruce SmithI think there was a survey done early in the year I think it was a PRCA survey, global survey and they interviewed a few hundred senior PR people and I couldn't believe the result, which said that allegedly one in four senior PR leaders said that they would never use AI. Never, I'm thinking. Well, are you close to retirement? Are you working for something we can avoid? So I think having nothing to do with it is not an option Patently. You need to do something, of course, on that is the thing that's vexing everybody. Well, where do you start? Where is it appropriate to utilize AI? Just because I can do something? Should I do it? What about the transparency with clients? We tell clients using AI well, you probably should. Is that enough? Do you need to tell them the tools you're using? Do you need to tell them exactly when you haven't used it?
Andrew Bruce SmithI've done a lot of many, many, many sessions now with agencies since the turn of the year around this topic, and I think that comes with a lot. Is this idea of well and PR is no different to the legal profession or the accounting profession, charging by the hour? What happens when clients say well, hang on, why are you charging me for four hours of time? Shouldn't you just take 10 minutes now? Why aren't you using AI to do it? I'll pay you for 10 minutes. I'm not paying you for four hours.
Will OckendenI look forward to that conversation.
Chris NortonI've got the report from the state of PR technology, which was from Powerly, and the question was how confident do you feel in your ability to use AI for PR tasks? And it was like it says satisfaction scores at 47% are confident in using AI for PR tasks. So that's for PR, but for marketing, it's marketing people in general. So give us what, are you sort of five key AI tools? Or do you just use GPT, because we've got a couple of tools here that we're using? In fact, I saw you using a transcript tool for the Teams call that we're on. Now. That's AI transcript, in that this podcast has its title done by AI. It's everywhere.
Will OckendenYeah, let's dig into those applications. So what are you seeing in your hundreds of conversations with marketers? How are people actually applying AI and what tools are they using to do it?
Andrew Bruce SmithI think when they are applying it, it's still in a relatively crude way. That's no disrespect to them, because of course you have to forget let's not forget chat GPT appeared last November. Literally, we're talking about seven or eight months of a time period where more has happened in seven months than probably the last 10 years. So it's understandable that we're human beings just trying to wrap our heads around the speed of development, the raft of new things and shiny things that are able to play around with. But it's going to break it down If you stick just with the generative AI aspect of things. Of course, for creating content, totally, there's a whole variety of ways in which you might use it to support the trade for content, although I think there is a there's people have to guard against, for example, just pushing the button and going great, that'll do, I'll just take what it gives me rather than look.
Andrew Bruce SmithThe human being still has to have the final say. So about oversight, about the quality of what it produces. Clearly, from a fact-checking standpoint, as that lawyer in the States turned to his cost, he used GPT for some court filings. Of course it made a whole bunch of stuff up. So now he's been fined, I think $5,000 in posthumous faces disbarment, that's just lazy. So kind of little sympathy around that one. But again the temptation, I guess, for people working in PR, comms and marketing to say let's push the button and just take what it gives us.
Chris NortonAndrew, have you used co-pilot at all? Microsoft's obviously, is part of an investment in open.
Andrew Bruce SmithAI. Only a privileged group of companies are on the Beater program. I've talked to a couple of who are, but no one's yet had the full nine yards yet of the whole co-pilot thing, although I noticed today that they've announced the pricing for it. So basically $30 per person per month is the premium?
Will OckendenWow. Do you want to explain exactly what it is and what it does for our listeners?
Andrew Bruce SmithI think the sympathy to look at it is Microsoft are going to add AI to every single one of their existing products. So Word, excel, powerpoint, teams, you name it they're all going to have AI capabilities. But I think, even more interestingly, it's the well. They say it's going to do this. We'll see whether it does it or it doesn't. But they produced a promotional video back in March and if it does half of what that promo video claims it's going to do, it's totally going to change everything. I mean the notion of having all this stuff interconnected. So you'd get I've just talked about code interpreter with chat, GPT.
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, what if that's already in Excel? I don't think it can go anywhere. It's already there. What about Word having AI capabilities? I don't need to go separately somewhere else to do it, it's just there. It's just available to you. Well, clearly, for a price which appears to be $30 a month per person. I noticed their share price apparently is now hitting all time high because investors think, yep, they've hit the goldmine here, because how many people are going to resist paying this $30 to get access to this very, very powerful additional capability?
Chris NortonSo a lot, isn't it extra $30 each.
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, yeah, I guess, do the calculation of the benefit envelope and you start to think about the potentially tens of billions of extra revenue that may come their way as a result. We'll see. We'll see how that pans out.
Chris NortonI mean, imagine having co-pilot in Outlook, right? So all of a sudden you've got emails from customers asking. You say you're working in a consumer BTC sector. Somebody sends in a complaint, you click co-pilot and co-pilot writes a response.
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, I have to say one live example of co-pilot because, interestingly, microsoft released a tool called Clarity a couple of years ago which was a hybrid of Google Analytics and Hotjar. You kind of think why is Microsoft releasing a Web Analytics tool? Aren't they a bit late to the game, aren't they? Yeah, yeah, but I installed it and kind of forgot about it. And then it was about a month ago. Somebody said, oh, you should have a real look at Clarity. I said why? Because it's already got co-pilot in it. They haven't really jumped up and down and told people, but it's there already. I thought, great, I'm going to check this out. So, co-pilot in Clarity you'll get a sense of what's coming.
Andrew Bruce SmithSo, before co-pilot, sure, you go in and there's a bunch of numbers telling you how many people viewed a page, blah, blah, blah. There might be this kind of analysis of an individual user. Oh, look, their cursor's moved around the page and there's the heat map. This is where they kind of lingered around. That's all fine and dandy. But imagine you've got like even 100 different sessions. You know human beings not going to sit there waiting through individual sessions to work it out.
Andrew Bruce SmithCo-pilot takes that and basically explains it to you in words that a five-year-old will understand. So it's saying, hey, this user you should pay attention to, because from the data it seems fairly obvious that they're a potential prospect, because we'll tell you which page is there the lingering on what we can infer from that. Can we infer from that that, yeah, they are displaying the behavior of someone that is more likely to be a paying customer than somebody else. So that's where the penny dropped. It's that idea of taking data that we were already capturing, but rather than the human being having to sit there and go right, what is this telling me? The AI kind of figures it out for you. It does that analysis. So when you extend that to everything else, then it starts to get really interesting. I mean just to go back to kind of the use cases of AI in PR and coms Some practical tests would be good.
Andrew Bruce SmithI think, think about it from the perspective of, let's say, your agency and you're pitching for a new client. How would you normally go about? Where you're going to gather information on you? Or what if you gather all that information and then simply give it to the AI and say hey, ai, you're a master creator of winning pitches for PR business. Given this, all this background information we've given you, give us your first pass recommendation of what to go back to the client with, and it will come back with a first pass recommendation. And my experience today is it's not bad. It's not bad, it's not bad.
Andrew Bruce SmithThe gating factor to date has been the so-called context window a little bit of jargon. So the context window is literally the kind of short-term memory of the AI. How much information can I input to the system? How much do I get back? So GPT, when it launched last November, had a context window about what? A couple of thousand words. So quite a bit. But you couldn't put in 10,000 words of background information because you wouldn't do anything with it. Gpt-4 expanded its context window. So we now are up to about what? 20,000 words or so. But Claude, which I mentioned earlier. Claude, too, has a 100,000 token context window. We're talking 75,000 words and it can handle spreadsheets, file formats. So get everything documents, put it in the hopper and go right. There you go. I've given you all the background information and I want you to output a 20,000 word initial recommendation and it's going to go ahead and do it.
Chris NortonOkay. So an agency owner out there, an agency employee out there, somebody out there working in a marketing agency, should they be worried? Are the jobs going to go avertable? What do you think? What's your take on it?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, I kind of agree with Sam Altman of OpenAI. This is his line, which he's been touting for some time, which is that the AI should be replacing tasks but not jobs. I kind of totally buy into that. Now, it may well mean that the nature of certain jobs are going to have to change, and this comes a lot. I mean particularly, for example, junior employees in PR firms sitting there going. Well, is that me out of a job? And it's like, well, it doesn't have to be.
Andrew Bruce SmithBut, quite frankly, if you have a job where every single one of your tasks can be replaced by AI, well, what kind of job have you got in the first place? Versus, I would say, the smarter agency owners will go. We need to reorient the nature of that role. If we're going to take all these tasks away from you, we're going to utilize your time in a different way. With an optimistic hat on, I see it as an opportunity to kind of upskill people more quickly in things that you may have. In the past, I said, well, you've got to sort of do a couple of years first, do all this stuff that, quite frankly, nobody else wants to do, but it has to get done and it's historically been more efficient to get a human being to do it. But now will the AI do all that kind of mundane rubbish and you can focus on being more creative about teaching people commercial skills from the day they start, rather wait a couple of years until they get up. So I'm just kind of speculating here.
Will OckendenWhere should we start then? We've talked about an awful lot of AI tools. We've talked about various applications. I know a lot of listeners are going to think right, we need to get on this.
Exploring AI Tools and Considerations
Will OckendenWhere did we start? Is there one tool in particular we should check out?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, that's part of the challenge. By some estimates, there have been about 20,000 new tools released, but in reality, the vast majority of them they're not really tools, they're features or they're just kind of clever wrappers around existing APIs. So it's just a nice wraparound access to, say, the GPT API. When people say what's the one tool that you would use, well, I guess it would be chat GPT or, strictly speaking, chat GPT plus because of the plugins, because that augments the capability of the core chat GPT tool. There are about 150 plugins now that do a whole variety of different things. Plus you've got the code interpret, et cetera. So if you pick one, that might be it. Conversely, because that has it quite pricey, isn't it? It's $20 a month. It's just one of you, but if you've got 100 people or 100 times 20, you can do the math. That suddenly starts to add up and of course, it's all very well giving people access to it, but there are no rule books. Have any of the AI companies produced any kind of documentation or guidelines as to how to use it? The short answer is no. I mean to be fair. Openai, a few weeks ago, did publish their guidelines to creating better prompts and it's quite good and I'd suggest everyone should go and have them look at it. But again, it's at a very, very sort of understanding that it's kind of very high level as opposed to, well, who's written the kind of these, the 50 sort of prompts you should start with in PR and marketing. But that hasn't been done yet. Or, if people have tried it, the danger is that it may be appropriate in certain contexts but not in others. There's no way around it. Really, the only way you learn by doing it's only by interacting with the tool, the technology. You'll start to figure out yourself what to do.
Andrew Bruce SmithBut the question of where to start because it's quite fundamental and if you're an agency, then it goes back to kind of rock bottom basics what are the kinds of organization, the clients that we're trying to serve? Let's examine our existing portfolio of services. Let's examine all of our different workflows. How do we do things now currently? How do any of those processes, can they be augmented or parts of those processes entirely replaced with AI? It's kind of process analysis. But I think for me the more exciting thing is the well, that's basically say, look, here's what we already do and can we make it sort of cheaper, quicker, etc. Versus might there not be entirely new ways of doing things that we haven't even thought of yet, that AI technology now makes possible? And I don't know on that one, but I can't believe there aren't going to be kind of brand new ways of approaching things.
Chris NortonSo the call to action then is basically go off and play around with the free version of chat to BT 3.5 or pay for the plus version, for which is more up to date. Now you pay in the extra $20 a month to get access to newer data, right?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, you're getting access to GPT4 if you don't get for in the free version also in the free version, half the time you can't even get in because it'll say sorry, it's overloaded, come back later. So if you want some kind of reliability of access, well I think the 20 bucks personally 20 bucks and it's a difference between having a career and not. I think that's a surprise worth paying.
Chris NortonMy question to you then is so obviously I think we said it was 10 times more intelligent. 4 is 10 times more intelligent than 3.5. When we get to chat GPT10, right? Is that a case of like the alien and Star Trek movies, where you go computer, tell me you know, and it will do calculations and everything and it is more intelligent than the human race? Is that where we're heading?
Will OckendenAnd to add to that, should we be afraid, Andrew, We've all seen terminated to. Should we be afraid?
Andrew Bruce SmithThere's nothing wrong with bit of fear. I'm definitely not complacent, but again, there's all bunch of things going on here. I mean, in fact, there's a piece, I think, today in the FT about the fact that the AI companies are basically running out of data to train their models on. It's kind of well, once you've scraped the entire internet and sort of pillaged every last existing set of data and you still need more, where are you going to get it from? Well, guess what.
Chris NortonThey're going to speak to each other, correct?
Andrew Bruce SmithYou get the AI to synthesize and create its own data. As interesting, demis Asabis is the CEO of Google DeepMind, which is a Brit and, if you hear me, I've never heard him speak before, but if you close your eyes, I thought he sounded like Jules Holland. Whilst I got to do anything, he's got a piano. He didn't at the time. What fascinated me with Demi? Well, first of all, I mean, he is number one person now at Google. He's in charge of all AI. So you know, deepmind is famously focused on solving kind of AlphaGo and it's been far more focused on kind of more kind of scientific use of AI. But they've gone right. You're going to run everything. And he was talking about how DeepMind have been used to solve this problem in kind of protein folding. What do I know about this? It's obviously very complicated and until now they were saying look, it would take a PhD student like sort of five years to kind of figure out one protein. It was like hundreds of millions of them. Yeah, at that rate, it's going to take us thousands of years to figure these problems out. Along comes AI and it's done it in a year a whole lot.
Andrew Bruce SmithAnd there, as he pointed out, the original dataset they had to work with was that wasn't very big. So that was an example where they used synthesized data to create the additional data. But then they didn't use all of it. They kind of took what they regarded as kind of the top 30% of the synthesized stuff, put that back into the model and then kind of went on from there. I know it seems kind of I don't need people here to hear the word synthesize, it will, it's just making stuff up and it kind of is. But from the perspective of but does it actually result in getting kind of the right ounce of popping out the other end? Then it would seem to me that that is a technique that can work in certain circumstances.
Will OckendenPresumably, there's quite an impact on search. Is there of AI? And I know this is something you spoke about a couple of weeks ago?
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, yeah. So first of all, ironically, we've all been affected by AI in search for nearly a decade. Google famously introduced RankBrain into its search algorithm back in 2015. So this is where AI is making decisions about what it shows you on that result page. You do a search, you see the search page and it's an AI that's kind of taking lots of those decisions about what it's going to show you. And a couple of years after that, the engineers who built RankBrain were quite happily saying, yeah, we built it, but we've no idea now how it arrives at the decisions it makes, and they didn't seem too bothered about it. They said, well, quite frankly, users aren't upset. It seems to be doing its job. So, yeah, a bit of a black box now, but crack on. So there's that part of it.
Andrew Bruce SmithBut the more practically impact now of chat GPT, of course, is that now that Microsoft introduced an AI chat box to Bing, Google have gone. We're going to do that as well, and I guess the challenge there is that, as we've seen with search over the last several years, the rise of so-called no-click searches. This is the idea that you do a search and the answer, if you will, to your queries right there on the search result page, so I don't need to click to go anywhere else. So if I produced an amazing piece of content and it's sitting in position number one, no clicks for you, because Google has effectively removed that traffic from you when they put that search box, that AI chat box, at the top of search, well, you can see what's going to happen.
Andrew Bruce SmithPeople will go there first. They'll put in their query, They'll get an answer back and will it make any reference to where that content came from? Well, all indications are at the moment it won't. And even if it did, how many people actually go? Oh, yes, well, I can see it's referenced 10 different underlying sources. I really must check them all out. I don't think so People go. Great, that'll do, I'll take that.
Will OckendenThanks very much. So totally game-changing potentially for the search industry and online PR industry.
Andrew Bruce SmithFor everybody. So for SEO, if, as I say, what's the point of being number one in Google if it's still not going to generate any traffic for you? What I mean it will, but the amount of traffic that you will get in the future compared to what you would have had in the past by occupying those top slots, well, it's a moot point, isn't it? We can see, with the big media, publishers are also saying well, hang on a minute, why we're creating this content which you, google, are scraping, an indexing, and we maybe certain publishers still didn't like the fact that they were scraping it, but that was a bargain. They had to strike because Google was still the biggest driver of traffic to media sites.
Andrew Bruce SmithBut what happens now? If Google scrapes your content, uses it to feed its AI model, gives you back an answer on the search result page and doesn't send you any traffic in return of doing it. Snip this I don't know if you've heard it. Why are we bothering? You know what? Maybe you will see publishers now tell Google's crawlers to where to go and say no, we're not going to let you. Then again, some of the big publishers are starting to negotiate deals with open AI, open up negotiations to basically pay publishers to allow them to take that content to fuel their AI's and so, in fact, in search, like most things in modern world, again, it's going to be impacted in some way by AI, so does this expose various ethical issues for us as marketers, then when should we?
Will Ockendenwhat considerations are there when it comes to ethics, then I know you've written extensively about this topic.
Chris NortonYeah, can I actually, before you go there, I can read the four points that I asked chat GPT to do a synopsis on it, and here are the key takeaways from the document, according to it. So this is the document, the CIPR's policy on AI, ai impiar, the guides, basically, and it says AI should be used in supplement human judgment, not replace it. Is that accurate? Pr professionals should be aware of the potential biases that can be introduced to AI systems? Absolutely, ai should be you. It wasn't biased when it wrote this. Ai should be used in a way that upholds the values of the PR profession, such as accuracy, honesty and transparency.
Chris NortonAnd then this one, which is interesting to me, and this is probably the one that Will was getting at PR professionals should take a leading role in the ethical development of AI in the PR industry. Okay, that's a great aspirational point to put in a document. How the hell can I have any impact? How can us three collectively have any impact or ethical control over what chat GPT are doing, barda doing LUMAR are doing? Does that mean, like you said right at the beginning of this conversation, it's an AI arms race? How can we have any sway in it whatsoever?
Andrew Bruce SmithWell, I think what that was referring to is more about the role of PR professionals advising clients or their own organizations, if they're in-house about the reputational implications of the use and deployment of AI by those organizations. So here what you're saying. You know what is Sam Altman, the boss of OpenAI, going to go? God, just look at that fantastic podcast with Chris Norton and Will Condonado Smith. They're so on the money. Quite right, hi, sam, thanks for joining us.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, welcome Sam. Come on the pod, we're plugged in. Yeah, fair enough, that's highly improbable, but at the same time, don't miss your words there, Andrew.
Andrew Bruce SmithThe AI industry, of course, is reliant upon the rest of the world adopting that technology. So if we're on the advising end of our organizations and somebody in CMA has got some bright idea, to say great, we can get rid of half the workforce and get AI to do it all for us, whereas the PR will advise. Well, if we do that, here's the likely knock on effect. It may seem like a wizard idea in the boardroom but quite frankly, it will destroy the company. So I'm kind of painting a kind of slightly exaggerated picture here, but that's the point.
Andrew Bruce SmithThere is absolutely a role PR and comms professionals to play, that advisory role to organizations about the, as I say, the reputation and implications of all this stuff. Now, that puts a premium on PR professionals and cells having a level of understanding of the technology to allow them to make those kinds of valid, credible and robust recommendations and advice. So, yeah, on that standpoint, I think it would be wrong for us to throw in the towel and say, well, what difference can we make? Because we can. I mean, individually, it might be sort of small and incremental, but collectively, yeah. And it's not just a PR sector. This is something that, without getting too grandiose about it. It affects every single person on the planet.
Chris NortonOh yeah, Ultimately so yeah, it's the biggest development since the wheel, is it not?
Will OckendenAndrew, you gave a quote about some big-wig at Google saying it's the biggest development since fire.
AI's Impact on Copyright and Creativity
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, so Sundar Pichai, CEO of Alphabet, obviously parent of Google, yeah, he said that AI is more important than fire or the wheel. This is indeed the biggest thing that the humanities ever come up with, and actually he said that a few years ago. I mean, this isn't a recent quote, he said it some years back and I know at the time people went, oh really that seems a bit over the top. And yeah, to be fair, I think he's probably right.
Chris NortonHave you seen the interview with Mo Gordat about AI and he talks about the fact that he said that the machines could get so clever by 2037. He's saying this could be so clever that in an ideal scenario, so we stop scaremongering. Right, they've helped us get jobs, they've helped everything. But he said they might just become so intelligent that they just see us as insects and just head out into the stars and like, because they've got no bio, bio body, you know they've got no, they've got no physiology, they're just electronic. And they they're so super intelligent beings.
Andrew Bruce SmithI've watched those videos, I've watched those, I've read those, those pieces by people with those kinds of views and opinions, and I know I still well hang on a minute that that that doesn't that sort of presuppose. We're just going to let them get on with it. I mean, we're still here at the moment and we still well we've I think we still got plenty of time for us to put in the necessary guardrails, or or or decide that we're hanging on a bit. Maybe GPT 20 is a step too far, you know. So, before we start racing off, you know, creating that sort of super duper version of it, then let's, let's maybe put the brakes on it and and there is a far more kind of involvement and consider it Because again, this is the things that move so fast, I mean gov'lence are behind the curtain.
Andrew Bruce SmithI mean, you take copyright as an example. We copyrights are mess when it comes to generative AI. I mean, according to I'm not a lawyer, but, as I understand, you know, current UK law, if I generate content with, you know, chat, gpt or mid journey or whatever, I own the copyright and the creative material. Fantastic, if I'm in America, I don't If I'm in Europe, they're focused on. Where was it created? Well, where was it created? Is it the server that belongs to to to open AI? That could be in America, or yeah, if I am not, but if I was, if I was in Paris tomorrow, I create it on my laptop. Does that mean it's now subject to French copyright law? But the minute I go back to London, suddenly it's mine again. Yeah, I mean, it's all over the place.
Chris NortonThe fascinating bit on that. I saw somebody else talking about that and there were an artist and they were saying you know, I create art and my my art's been used to train these machines to make pictures like mid journey. The one you were referencing is one example. But at the end of the day, aren't all artists taking their own impression of all other people that have ever been? Anyway, we're all you know. We've gone back to cave paintings or whatever. They don't own the copyright. If, like you're saying there, if you generate that image, but then do you generate that image in the style of Salvador Dali, for instance?
Andrew Bruce SmithCorrect, and again that that is absolutely argued, that the AI companies are taking. They're, they're taking the fair use route. They're saying, look, you know we're not copying you, but it's kind of providing, if you will, the, the, the inspiration to generate this, this new stuff. When the US copyright office is saying that the, that their current stance appears to be well, can you copyright pure AI generated content? If I modify in some way, does that suddenly change the game? But of course they're not telling you about by how much. If I take a mid journey image and I'm in America and I change a couple of pixels, well, look, I've had some input to that. So suddenly you know I get to copyright it because I've just amended a couple of pixels. Yeah, or what, what? How much human input is required to turn it into something that, that that isn't sort of purely AI generated. And yes, I mean I'm not.
Andrew Bruce SmithI'm not saying I've got no sympathy at all with, with artists and creatives of any kind. I mean, look at, look at Getty images. I mean they're suing everybody and they've got a point. You know all the AI image companies that have relentlessly crawled and accessed every image they can find from Getty to put into their model and they didn't ask permission to do it. They haven't paid Getty a penny and they're using it to generate new AI based content and in some cases, they are charging people to use those, those tools and services.
Andrew Bruce SmithSo, getty, going the legal route, you've got shut a stock in exactly the same industry and they've said there's no point fighting this. Yeah, they've. They've. They're starting to do deals with the AI companies saying look, we're going to license our content to you and fill your boot. Yeah, adobe, yeah, adobe. But a month ago made that really bold claim, didn't they? They said look, we've got our own massive bank of copyright material to use from. We'll let you use that to generate content via AI. And they're saying currently, if you encounter any issues around copyright by doing so, we'll pay your legal fees. Whoa, wow. Now whether they'll continue to make that offer, I don't know, but I think that's that's clearly a very confident statement of intent from their perspective, that they think we're on pretty solid ground when it comes to this.
Chris NortonI could literally talk about this for another three hours, but we're almost out of time, so we have got the question. We have the question for you.
Will OckendenI'll let you do it this week because I think I messed it up last week, didn't I?
Chris NortonYeah, so we've covered AI today, but this show is all about fuckups in people's careers and what they've learned from them. And so, Andrew, give what's the biggest fuckup you've made in your career and what did you learn from it? This is always my favorite bit.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, yeah, yeah, god, there's plenty of them.
AI in PR and Marketing
Andrew Bruce SmithI guess to. One of those springs to mind very, very early in my career, when I started out as a journalist. In fact, I began working for the retail news agents magazine and so for the first year as an editorial assistant, they didn't really let me out. And then finally one of those right, okay, I'm going to give you your first press conference to go to. And in fact they did use the phrase don't fuck it up, because it was the launch of the today newspaper. It was 986. This is a big deal, first national newspaper launch in about 100 years.
Andrew Bruce SmithAnd there was a little me from the retail news agent sitting on a bus going off to Poyle near Heathrow to go to the printing press where Eddie Shaw was going to push the button to kind of launch the presses, and sat there with the great and the good of Fleet Street thinking, oh, you know, I would told don't come back unless you get an exclusive interview with Eddie Shaw. And you know, here's the camera. You know, go and get some good pictures. Like I've never taken a proper picture of my life and it's like what. So all the bus we get there and the great and the good of Fleet Street surround the console where Eddie Shaw is going to push the button to launch the press and I'm stuffed here. You know I can't get an interview. Where can I get a good picture? And I look behind me and there was this huge gantry. I thought that's a brilliant spot. I'll go up there. There's nobody up there, brilliant. I'm going to get an amazing picture of Eddie Shaw pushing the button. So I get up there and he's just about to push the red button and he looks up and he sees me and he says so wouldn't stand there if I were you and the whole Fleet Street turns around and sees me.
Andrew Bruce SmithI was standing on the printing press. I would have become front page news for all the wrong reasons if you pushed the button and the whole of Fleet Street In full color as well, I believe, in full color, absolutely. But the whole of Fleet Street, the whole lot of them just burst out laughing and I thought that's it, my career is finished. So I trudged down the steps going. I'm going to go back. I failed. I've got no interview, I've got no picture. I've humiliated myself on my first day with the whole of Bloody Fleet Street. But to his eternal credits. Eddie Shaw sought me out. He said you knew it. This time I'm like, yes, so come here. So he got to tip my hat to him. He gave me five minutes of his time. I got my interview, I got some shots with him, but that's because he practically sought me out and honestly felt bloody sorry for me, but yeah that was an awesome.
Chris NortonI tell you what mate, yeah, but you, I bet he remembers you as well. He'll remember that and that, which is quite an accurate one You've got so many people in the crowd.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, yeah, see, maybe I got a taste of PIC. So how do you get attention?
Will OckendenWell, and it could have been a lot worse hadn't it, had you tripped and fallen back into the printing press Flat. Stanley yes, flat Andrew. Yeah, well, that was an excellent fuck up, andrew. Thank you very much for that. It's almost as good as our technical fuck up at the beginning. So I think probably let's get you back. We'll probably get you back on the show in about a year and there'll be whole new swathes of developments in AI, so let's make it a regular thing. That was absolutely fascinating.
Andrew Bruce SmithI'll send my AI doppelganger next time, won't I, because I've created a clone by then.
Chris NortonWe'll put all the details of how to book. So do you want to tell us a bit about you've got your workshops, don't you? Do you want to get your plug in for your workshops and we'll put the link in the show notes.
Andrew Bruce SmithYeah, sure, I mean I run AI PR workshops through both the CIPR and the PRCA. I mean I do direct training and consulting for those that want it. So, yeah, I'm always available to help people with their agency side in-house teams. There's clearly a huge, huge demand in this area at the moment. But, yeah, if you want to have a chat about what might be appropriate, sure, bring it on.
Chris NortonGreat. Well, thanks for coming on the show, andrew, given us your time. That's great, honestly fascinating, and I could do like I say we could do another hour or two on this because there's so much to talk about in terms of AI. But I think Will's right. I think we should have a reconvene in 25 shows time and get you on and talk about and find out how things have changed and how the fact that you've been replaced by an AI and you've just got all that's left as a digital beard- that's right.
Andrew Bruce SmithYes, as I say I. What a way to go. What?
Will Ockendena way to go.
Andrew Bruce SmithGiven what's happened over the last seven or eight months, I mean, yeah, my mind's boggles at what will happen in the coming seven or eight months. So in a year, yeah, yeah, let's just do it again and let's see how much has changed.
Will OckendenSo that was absolutely fascinating, wasn't it, chris? I think you can't bury your head in the sand any longer, can you when it comes to AI as a marketer?
Chris NortonNo, I think. Well, andrew's got some fascinating takes. I mean, ai is fascinating and there's lots of different opinions on what it's going to do to the world. Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing is up to you. It is going to take jobs, but what I've heard is it's going to take jobs. It's not the AI that's going to take the jobs. It's people using AI that are going to remove the tasks, which is what Andrew was saying too. So that bit was interesting to me. The other really interesting bit that I took out of that was the copyright discussion. That is an, he said, a mess. It's a nightmare. Copyright Copyright in different countries is a nightmare, but the fact that people can't agree on who owns what and why.
Will OckendenYeah, absolutely, and I think the other key outtake that I got from that was really there's no playbook for how marketers should use AI at the moment, and it's really just a case of getting involved in the platforms and discovering it yourself, isn't it? Yeah, and really finding out ways how it can streamline your operations, how it can support you creatively, how it can support your copywriting. We just need to figure it out ourselves, don't we?
Chris NortonYeah, I mean he spoke that in depth. I've got 20 questions here and I got through two and I'm not sure we got all the answers. So there's so much to cover with AI and using AI and marketing. There's tons of tools. I mean he recommended that you should use ChatGBT for this barred and then there's a few others, but we're using a couple of content marketing ones that basically ride on the success of that and plug into. So there is some really great tools out there, but just using the free one. If you're not doing anything, your staff should be using the free stuff just to test it for ideas, to test it on create, because the content's not brilliant, you'll know well. You've seen some of the content. The articles are on four of the miles better, but an article written by 3.5 feels a bit I don't know. It's not got that depth that a real good writer would have. It's sort of like the beginnings of a great article, but then that's okay, isn't it?
Will OckendenIt should augment your writing. As Andrew said, you should never treat that as the finished article. It's a starting point which you then no pun intended, which you then finesse. I think our listeners will probably be quite interested in hearing more about some of those practical applications of AI, particularly in comms and marketing. So we're actually running a podcast in a few months, aren't we, on AI in PR and marketing.
Chris NortonNo, this is a podcast.
Will OckendenSorry, we're actually running a webinar in a few months on AI's role in PR and social media, which is actually really going to dig into those practical applications. So how to use AI to generate scripts, how to use AI to generate ideas, how to use it in a copyrighting context. So if you head to prohibitionprcouk and then click our events section, you can actually register for that event. So make sure you don't miss out.
Chris NortonYeah, I mean tons to cover, lots to cover, and it's constantly changing. So I think we should renew this conversation once every six months. You said once every year, but I'm at a year to think that it only came out in October. I mean, that's just over half a year and now it's already cleverer than Einstein. It's mental.
Will OckendenIt is mental when you think about that. And just to conclude, I think Andrew spoke to me a few weeks ago about a really interesting application of AI, which is actually voice cloning. So in theory, you could ask AI to write you a script. You could then turn that into a video and you could actually clone your voice. So in theory, next episode of this podcast we could actually do 100% with AI and we don't even need to turn up to the room.
Chris NortonIt wouldn't be as good at the jokes as me and you, though, would it really Doubtful? Thanks for tuning in to episode four. These episodes are coming out every fortnight on a Tuesday, so the next episode look, check you, check you wherever you get your podcast from every Tuesday. We're also sending every version of this to our YouTube channel, so be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel, because we love and want to see all your comments, and remember to tell us your biggest fuck up, because they do make us laugh. Send them in, please, to sociallyuaprohibitionpruk. That's sociallyuaprohibitionpruk. Or send somebody else's in, and we'll do anything for a laugh and we'll see you next week.
Vicki MurphyThank you for listening to socially unacceptable. Please remember to subscribe to the podcast and leave us a five star review. Don't forget to follow us on social media on Twitter and Instagram at prohibitionpr, we would love to hear some of your career fuck up so we can share them on the show. For more information on the show, search prohibitionpr in your search engine and click on podcasts. Until next time, please keep pushing the boundaries and embracing the socially unacceptable.