Embracing Marketing Mistakes
Embracing Marketing Mistakes is the show that teaches you growth from failure.
Every week, the Founder of Prohibition PR, Chris Norton and his co-host, Will Ockenden, sit down with the people behind some of marketing's best-known brands and ask the question most interviews avoid: what went wrong, and what did you do next?
Rand Fishkin, Richard Shotton, Ben Branson, Phil Barden and Roger Dooley have all owned up. So have marketers from Yorkshire Tea, Lexus, Adobe, Deliveroo and Ogilvy.
You hear about the campaigns that flopped and the calls they got wrong, told honestly and with a sense of humour. Then you get the lesson, so you can skip the expensive part.
A top 10 UK marketing podcast on Apple, with 135+ interviews and 550,000 downloads across 172 countries. New episode every week.
If you have a story to tell and would like to appear on the show, tell us your biggest marketing mistake and drop us a line.
Embracing Marketing Mistakes
EP 6: Top Red Flags in Client Pitches and How to Avoid Bad Deals - Chris Simmons
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Ever wondered what it takes to run a successful digital agency? Join us as we navigate the nuances of agency leadership and the importance of understanding your numbers, accompanied by Chris Simmance, founder of OMG Center, and the mastermind behind Optus Digital. With a wealth of experience in digital strategy and SEO, Chris takes us through his journey from a travel salesman to the bustling world of digital marketing.
Dive into the common pitfalls that agency owners often stumble upon in their business operations, and discover how to sidestep them. Chris imparts his insights on boosting business performance through understanding numbers and the significance of client retention. Additionally, we examine how to lead score potential clients, set expectations for payment terms, and measure success and scale, with Chris sharing his rule of seven for agency advisors.
But the conversation doesn't stop there. Chris talks about the stages of business growth, the difference between management and leadership, and how to engage your team with a clear vision. We also discuss training and development for agency owners, and the need to stay ahead of industry trends. So, put on your headphones and get ready to revolutionize your agency leadership with us and Chris Simmance. num36sfh
Do you have a F*ck up to share?
Your competitors are being named by AI. Are you? One of our clients went from being named in 4 of 50 buyer prompts to 19 in 90 days. Book your free AI visibility check with Chris here. 👉 [Book free AI Visibility Check] 👈
Subscribe to our newsletter
The mistakes we see marketers make, every fortnight. 👉 [Subscribe here] 👈
Follow Chris:
X, TikTok, LinkedIn
Follow Will:
LinkedIn
Follow The Show:
TikTok, YouTube
Agency Mistakes and How to Resolve
Chris SimmanceThe vast majority of the reason why agencies lose their clients isn't usually because of results, unless you're a terrible agency. You usually lose clients because either you've not set expectations properly or they've not managed to set expectations properly.
Will OckendenYou kind of gave a couple of areas that look really interesting. Do you want to talk to us about some of those big kind of mistakes that agencies make consistently and how they can perhaps resolve those.
Chris SimmanceSo if you consider trying to do the right positioning and messaging, your marketing will fail if your website headline says something hyperbolic, like we do everything for everyone, buy it all right now here, because you can't maintain consistency.
Will OckendenSo is the agency model broken then? I read a lot about this kind of the traditional agency model.
Chris SimmanceThe model's not broken. What you just said is broken about the model. Leadership is a huge amount more personal ownership and accountability. Leadership is a lot more consistency required. You need to really know who you are before you can lead.
Vicki MurphyWelcome to socially unacceptable, from f*ck ups to fame, the marketing podcast that celebrates the professional mishaps, mistakes and misjudgments, while delivering valuable marketing and life lessons in the time it takes you to eat your lunch.
Chris NortonOkay, thanks everybody. Welcome to the show. Today we're lucky to have on the line Chris Simmons, and he is the founder of OMG Center, which aims to accelerate the growth of digital agencies through consultancy, mentorship, training and support. He's also worked in several digital marketing agencies, working mainly in SEO and digital strategy, and then, as chairman at OCTUS Digital, he built up the search-based digital agency to offices in London and Manchester. So how's that for an introduction, Chris? Have I got that right?
Chris SimmanceI mean you've condensed I think about 12 years into about 45 seconds, so that feels about right.
Chris NortonOkay, good, thanks for coming along, thanks for joining us, I mean we've followed you.
Chris SimmanceIt's nice to be on the other side of the microphone.
Chris NortonExactly, yeah, so I mean, what I have missed off there is that you I've put here that you speak at events across the world. You look at how digital agencies tick and you look and you also run the popular podcast which is interesting, which is the digital agency podcast, and we have an office dog. Is that right?
Chris SimmanceIndeed, he's right behind me there.
Will OckendenYeah.
Chris NortonI saw that bit.
Will OckendenThat's a good plug. So what advice can you give us for a podcast then, Chris? I'm intrigued.
Chris SimmanceAll success, in every fashion, comes from consistency, so get it done, keep going. Most of the time, no one knows when you've made a mistake, so just keep going with it.
Will OckendenThat's reassuring to hear.
Chris NortonWe just tend to piss ourselves when we make a mistake because the show is about mistakes. And we've been told not to swear in the first two minutes, according to the YouTube situation. I mean I'm fascinated to hear your story. I mean you said I've packed it into 45 seconds there, but actually it's deliberate because I'd like to hear a little bit about your background. So do you want to just walk us through your career and how you've got to where you are today and what you do today?
Chris SimmanceYeah, okay, yeah, sure. So, speaking of background, in the background you'll see several snowboards and several skateboards, longboards, electric boards. I like board sports. Over the course of a 10 year period, I lived over in ski resorts in chalets and repping and ski guiding and things like that.
Chris SimmanceEventually, when I physically couldn't do that anymore because you know the knees go and other health matters I had to come back to the UK and whilst I was convalescing I had to find a job. And I had no qualifications, no experience professionally beyond customer service type stuff, so I got a job in a travel agents trying to sell holidays. That didn't work out very well because it was a high street travel agents, and who's going into high street travel agencies apart from you know, older people and things like that? So you know planes were in the sky, holidays were moving, things were happening and I thought, well, the internet must be where it's all going on. So I taught myself SEO, found an agency crazy enough to take me on and within a year and a half or so I'd moved up to London and then packed agency employment in to build my own.
Chris NortonAfter a year and a half?
Chris SimmanceYeah.
Chris NortonSo you worked for an agency for a year and a half and you went 'I can do this better than that'.
Chris SimmanceYeah, that's it.
Chris NortonSo how old were you at this point?
Chris Simmance20, 12 years ago, so 24 I think, if that my maths is right.
Chris NortonI mean that's some confidence, that to be in a job for a year and a half.
Chris SimmanceYeah, I'm not sure on that, I'm not sure on confidence, I'm afraid.
Chris NortonOkay, good. Well, that's good, all right. And then what happened?
Chris SimmanceYeah, so ran the agency for nearly nine-ish plus years about four years before we round it down I started up a web development business at the same time and they ran concurrently.
Chris SimmanceSo I was running two agencies at the exact same time, which is stupid, and I learned that through, you know, a lot of tired and sleepless nights. But the reason they were separated was because the web development business was building websites which digital agencies clients would want. So we were selling websites to other agencies and when I was doing that I was realizing actually, to be perfectly honest, there's quite a good industry here. I was in my own agency island for quite a while and didn't realize that lots of the things I hear over the negotiation table were pretty much the same problems I have, and just realized that you know, there's a lot to learn running an agency, there's a lot of mistakes that can get made and an awful lot of those mistakes cost people money. So I exited the web development business, wound the digital agency into a consultancy and then started helping other agency owners build their business instead, because it's way more fun, and I'm a lot better at it.
Will OckendenSo you must have a fascinating inside track on the challenges agencies face, the big mistakes they make. In the kind of the pre-show briefing you kind of gave a couple of areas that look really interesting. Do you want to talk to us about some of those big kind of mistakes that agencies make consistently and how they can perhaps resolve those?
Chris SimmanceYeah, which one do you want to talk about first? In particular? Because I mean, I talked to people about this all week long, every week, so this podcast could be quite long.
Will OckendenThe one that grabbed me really was multi-service agency offering everything to everyone, and I think that's you know when you're a full-service agency a tendency, isn't it? Let's just sell a lot of stuff to a lot of people, let's try and do everything. Is that the wrong approach?
Chris SimmanceIt can be yeah and so if you consider trying to do the right positioning and messaging, your marketing will fail. If your website headline says something hyperbolic like we do everything for everyone, buy it all right now here, because you can't maintain consistency, it's really hard to sell SEO, PPC, email, CRO and content marketing, digital PR to a fashion brand and to an e-commerce company and to a travel brand and get it consistent. So at some point the balance tips to it either costs you too much to deliver a consistent service and not churn in clients, or it costs too much to bring in clients because you have to go heavy on different types of marketing. So usually you work out in the positioning right, you're talking to the right people at the right time in the right way. You're only saying the same thing that resonates with them better. So you can deliver all of those services but to an individual niche. Or you can deliver one service to many people but then your messaging is very much more clear. With the SEO agency for everyone but we only do SEO, or we're the full service marketing agency for travel brands means that all of your messaging or your marketing/ case studies everything lines up with that, you can be experts in one or the other fashion.
Chris SimmanceThe problem is that most agencies and I did this and quite a lot of agencies do this as you start out and cash flow is the killer, you need cash, so you say yes to everything. You take everything on, you make the error of essentially taking things on potentially too low value. Someone says, hey, you're doing the SEO and the PPC. Do you reckon you can do the email? You go I've used Mailchimp once, of course, yeah, absolutely. Then you have an email marketing service that you suddenly spin up and it then becomes untenable eventually because more and more clients will want other things and you then don't have experts in the in the single subject matter. You've got people doing everything everywhere and when one of them goes you, then how are you going to replace that thing?
Chris NortonI learned that lesson right at the beginning, even before Will joined me here at Prohibition. When I started out, people would be like, 'oh, you do blogs, you do. .. ' because it was right at the time, right at the beginning of social media, before anyone knew how to use it really. And then I was meeting people and they're asking me to build websites and I was going 'oh yeah, we can do that.
Chris NortonI'll do that in WordPress. ' Started doing it and then before I got maybe four websites in and thought this is not for me. I do not want to do this. This isn't where my skills are.
Chris SimmanceIt's got to be a massively high sort of level of masochism to want to be a web developer, because I've never in the time even running an agency that built them for agencies. You'd think that we get briefing properly and we get project management properly. There's far too many interconnected random bits, and then you add a bit of flavor of creativity and it all falls down yeah, I don't think you can. It's a horrible, horrible business. If you're running a web dev business and you're listening to this, why?
Will OckendenSo, um, this idea of kind of niching um, niching the agency and really kind of focusing on what you want to do, what you're good at, where you can at the most value. How you know for agencies or consultants you know starting that journey of building an agency, how soon should they do that do you need to stick to your guns and really think okay, what do I want to do? What sectors do I have a great knowledge in?
Chris SimmanceYeah. So there's there's a couple of things to do. First of all, if you're really really good and you've got a really good base, like a good base of in your network, then it might be easier to niche early doors because you know that those people know you're good at one thing and then when you kind of put the sign up and says, hey, I'm in business', people will come, uh, from that, that perspective, and you'll have plenty of work in.
Chris SimmanceFor the most part, the the best thing to do is kind of look at what you love doing, then what you're really good at doing, that you love doing, and then what you're really good at doing, that you love doing, that you can also make a decent amount, decent amount of cash out of. And then you decide is that a skill or is that an experience-based thing? So if it's an experience-based thing, it might well be travel, and therefore you match the skills to the area. If it's a experience, a skill-based thing, you then say, 'okay, it's just search or it's just paid'. Because I enjoy social media, I'm really good at paid ads on social media. I therefore should be doing social media, paid ads only.
Chris NortonSo you've done 60 podcasts. I think this is episode 6 or 7. I need to track when the next one's coming out for us.
Common Mistakes in Running Agencies
Chris NortonSo you've spoke to at least 60 founders or business owners, and you speak to people every day. What's the common? What are the common biggest mistakes that you're seeing in running agencies?
Chris SimmanceUm, so most agency leaders start agencies because they're really good at the thing that they're delivering. They do what I did. They go, I'm a bit better than the person that's employing me right now, so I'm going to go do it for myself. They very quickly then end up accidentally getting into the exact same service model delivery that they left, and they just have their logo and the nice documents instead. So the majority of agency leaders are great at the delivery of the thing. It's the running of the business that is often the problem, and they are businesses.
Chris SimmanceThey're great fun, you can be really creative, you can have your beanbag and you can have all your cool stuff. But you've got to run them like businesses and the only way to do that is to really understand the numbers. Like, what is the net profit margin on an individual client? No one, in almost no one I ever speak to knows that specifically, but you should have a scorecard, a cost calculator for every single client. You should know what your OPEX is.
Chris SimmanceThe second you increase a new member of staff. You should know immediately how many more X's and Y's you need when you bring in another member of staff or another client. What does the API credit mean? Uh, if you then need to to call on that for four more clients, well it's usually 50 quid a client, but it's not going to be if you're bringing one that's a 10 million page website and it's got loads of stuff going on. So you've got to know your numbers, understand the impact of that, and the majority of the time, not knowing your numbers means you make decisions that then impact something later down the line. You get in this hamster wheel of get client, lose client, find staff, lose staff, get client, lose client, find stuff, lose stuff, burn out. Stop, do it all again, reinvent yourself and start again, and it doesn't actually um, it doesn't actually change anything, unless you kind of know where you're going and what the numbers are.
Will OckendenThat's an interesting point and yeh, I think with growing agencies you can get to a certain point without really needing to have too much of a handle on that, can't you?
Will OckendenBut then every agency hits that tipping point where suddenly it becomes a bigger, fully functioning business where there's you know a big payroll, there's numbers to hit each month and I think a lot of agencies probably, you know like like you say, they have plenty of training in the technical side of things, but actually guess what? HR finance, um, running a business, they just learn on the job, which is is the wrong, the wrong way to look at it.
Will OckendenSo is the agency model broken? Then I quite, I read a lot about this kind of you know, the traditional agency model. Um, you know a lot of agencies will invest, you know 60% of their time winning new businesses. Clients drop out the bottom and they're stuck in this cycle of pitching for business, winning new business, losing business. And yeah, is that the wrong model?
Chris SimmanceThe model's not broken. What you just said is broken about the model. And so there's far too many different sort of niche elements to this. But the majority of agencies, if they focus on better client retention, then any new clients coming in on top increases their profit margins. If they're focused on client retention but they don't work on their marketing, then they just have stagnation. There's a you know four post balance. It's like one of those seesaw's that you've got four or five sides to it. You can't you focus on one thing. Another thing isn't going to work out that well. So running them like a business, you should have these things in a deep kind of equitable balance.
Chris SimmanceIf I'm looking at clients dropping out the bottom, that client cost money to bring in. It cost money to maintain. You might have made a profit on it. That was a relatively decent profit, but it didn't impact your cash flow very well because you've now got to replace that client when they drop out. That means the cost of delivering a new client in increases with every new client. That means eventually you're eroding your cash flow and your overall margins and you've just got loads of cash coming in the bank and you think you're great and you think you're rock stars, but you're not. You've got to realize that five percent increase in decreasing client churn is actually probably more valuable to you than than sticking I don't know 10 grand on awards.
Chris NortonYou said at the beginning that you learn. You learned to become a mentor and a coach. Is it business coaching that you'd say that you do?
Chris SimmanceSo I like to call it agency advisory, because coaching implies that you've got something to fix or there's a problem. The advisory aspect comes when people are asking for help.
Chris NortonI'm not so sure it does I mean like coaching for me? Well, we've been going 12 years and so coaching for me, I'm massively into coaching. I had a coach before Will joined the business. I had a coach when I started out and I've had a coach pretty much every other year of the last 12 years because you don't know what you don't know and a coach isn't there to tell/ give you all the answers.
Chris NortonThey're there to coach you into the scenarios and get you to improve how you operate. Basically, and what you've just talked about there, like the agency model, people. I remember, I was in a pitch years ago and this guy said to me 'your agency model is outdated, it's all going to change, everyone's going to outsource' and that hasn't happened.
Chris NortonThat was six/ seven years ago and then consequently, they went out of business and agencies are still the same way, other than the technology that's changing, the software, AI and all that stuff that's coming out. I still believe the agency model, like you say is right, but I do believe in coaching. So you said that you've learned from your mistakes. This show is all about.
Chris NortonI can swear now, fuck ups. This show is all about fuck ups. So come on then, give us your fuck ups. What fuck ups have you made that you've learned and you pull into your mentorship and your agency advisory role?
Chris SimmanceSo, from a leadership and management perspective, I let the emotional aspect of the business impact the way I worked with the team, so client left. I took an emotional personal feeling behind that rather than how can we make this not happen again, which then made me a pretty bad manager/ leader, and I think that you know, as a big mistake was probably anyone listening to this that worked with me when I ran one of the agencies will probably be nodding right now and going 'yeah, that guy's a dick' and they'll never not think that I'm a dick.
Chris SimmanceBut you know, sometimes you realize that it's your business, it's your baby, all the wins are someone else's, all the losses are yours. And sometimes you get a punch in the face and metaphorically, a client leaves or something happens, something goes wrong, and you shouldn't but you do take it out on someone else. And that was that that I learned the hard way, because I realized introspectively later I shouldn't have done that and you can't apologize for that later. It doesn't work just by saying sorry.
Chris SimmanceAnd the other stuff was genuinely I did not have a proper handle on the numbers. I thought I did. I had management accounts, had all that sort of stuff, but cash flow was what was coming in and I thought we were doing great. And then, when one or two clients left in the same period of time just as you've hired one or two members of staff in the same period of time you suddenly realize, 'ah crap, where's the VAT bill coming from? ' And you haven't really provisioned for it properly.
Chris SimmanceThere are a lot of agencies that are probably thinking right now, as they're listening to this, ' I'm doing that right now, crap, okay'. And that's what happens a lot because I thought I got it, I thought I had a handle on it, I didn't. And when I did eventually get a handle on it, I kind of realized that I've learned, I've learned something significant here and this isn't worth kind of just sitting in one box. Hence starting the second agency, and I own a few other businesses outside of the digital industry and all of that's come from learning these things that I've just kind of, I say happened upon but been open to learning as I go.
Will OckendenThat's interesting about cash flow, I mean things like that. It seems so obvious, doesn't it? But it's not. You know, when you're in the trenches, when you know, and agencies are busy and hectic, aren't they? You know, it's very long hours, it's very often demanding clients. That stuff isn't always obvious is it when you're in a situation? No, no, no.
Chris NortonAnd like what he says there, if you're winning clients. You know you might have 30/ 40 clients and you're winning stuff regularly and you maybe you lose a couple. You're winning, you hire somebody to help you facilitate that client and then you lose a couple and then you don't realize what you've lost. And it can easily be done. It sounds obvious when you talk, when you take a step back, the helicopter view, I think.
Chris NortonBut if you're in the trenches like Will says, and you're just getting on with the day- to- day running the business. You know somebody's off poorly or you know all the different scenarios and hats you have to wear is running a company and before you know it, you three months in and you've got the VAT bill like you say.
Will OckendenSorry, yeah, I was going to say when you.
Chris NortonI was going to say you might?
Will OckendenWe're going to clip that bit. Yeah, we'll clip that out. I'll start again. Yeah, I think when you're in that growth phase of an agency, often the problems can just be papered over, can't they? You know, you don't necessarily spot those, but it's only when you platter/ you lose a client, that all these things suddenly become obvious and the wheels start to fall off.
Chris SimmanceYeah, you take on let's say for argument's sake, we're recording this end of July. So beginning of August, you bring in two new clients, they're a significant size. They've got 90 day payment terms because of how their finance works. You've agreed to that. You've got 90 plus days before you see the first penny from those clients. But during July you lost two semi decent clients that paid on 30 days terms. You've got a huge hole in the cash flow. And if loads of money's coming in that's kind of papers over it, so to speak and your P&L doesn't reflect that your cash flow does. And you start looking at your bank balance and the bank balance is, if you're doing it properly, go down ever so slightly and you start going 'oh okay, we've got all this. The P&L says good, everything looks good. But actually there's cash in the bank which is going down here and we should have at least three, and a bit months of cash in the bank here and we don't now. What's happened? ' And you then diagnose it later.
Chris NortonYou're giving me anxiety, that's bad payers. Right, running an agency like we want to work with great clients. We work with some great ones. We've actually turned down pitches we've won because some clients have been on more than 90 days payment like 90 days to pay your agency that are working for you. You know we've got 30 staff working hard at it. We've got to pay all their salaries, like you say, and you've got to wait 90 days just to get your bill paid and then if they pay late, it just isn't
Will OckendenNo, that's right. I mean why people can't pay on time, I don't know. But that I think every industry suffers from that, doesn't it?
Chris SimmanceYeah, it's business wide, should we say. But like one of the things we put in our lead scoring was, and there's no point in going through the whole pitching process to then get to the end and kind of see a massive red flag. And you can mitigate that and sort of say, have they given us a brief? Yes, 10 points. Are they in an industry we like? No, minus five points. Do they have payment terms of 30 days or less? Yes, plus 10 points. And if it's 90 days, you go. It's a massive red one straight away and speak to someone that might want it instead.
Chris NortonBut it's all down to like the brand because, like you know, oh Samsung would like you to pitch for this. Oh sorry, Samsung. It's always the big, great, blue chip clients that okay, great, yeah, we'd love to work with you, and then you obviously wouldn't. The first question is... so about your tender, we'd just like to ask you what are your payment terms? And they go 120 days. We'll do it anyway, because Samsung you
Will OckendenYeah well, actually let's dig into that. That's really interesting. So those you know, I think pitching is hugely expensive and hugely time consuming. So what are those red flags
Red Flags in Agency Pitches
Will Ockendenagencies should look out for, you know because it's quite a bold move, isn't it? Rejecting a major brand in a pitch, you know it can be demotivating for the team. So what should we look out for?
Chris SimmanceWell, I think it comes down to the early doors lead scoring that you do internally. So you get that request for proposal, request for information from them and you read that intently and you look at that against your typical lead scoring process. So is the brief full? Do you have scoring? Do they have scoring for how they choose? How many people are you pitching against? Etc. And then, if there's not a you know, at the end of the RFP or the RFQ there's usually the dates that stuff will happen. One of the first sets of dates should be like there's an open week to ask a single set of series of questions. So in those questions, any questions you don't have answered in the RFP, that's when you should be saying what are the payment terms, what are the layers of sign off, because it's not written in there.
Chris SimmanceThat should make a big impact, because if it is 120 days and you don't want to wait 120 days to get paid because it's going to be a two month proposal period and it's going to take a lot of effort and it's going to take the team out of things; that's opportunity cost as well. You should be looking at what's the cost of delivering this proposal to the business, and it's going to be four people all over the course of three weeks, which is going to account for about £6,000 to maybe be scored against another agency or three on fair scoring metrics. But then I have to wait 120 days for the money and like with my external hat on looking into agencies. My advice would always be; be honest, be polite, because the world is relatively small nowadays. So look, I'd love to pitch, love to do this, but the terms of this don't suit my business. So, thanks very much. I can recommend someone to speak to if you'd like. Inside the agency years ago, I would have probably been pigheaded enough to take it on.
Chris NortonYou know you've just mentioned there like pigheaded as a not for you personally. But you know, like you just said, well Will and I run a agency. I've met a few. I've got a few friends that run agencies, but I don't know a million people. I know I see them on Twitter, I'm friends with a lot on Twitter, but not don't sit down and chew the fat with them about...
Chris NortonI s there commonalities between agency owners that you see like in the personalities and the character of how they are? Are we quite all pigheaded, to use your term?
Chris SimmanceYeah, I mean for the most part there's a competitive aspect to the personality that you need to have in order to do a business like this. And you also like I mean, if you forget agency people, you just think digital marketing people in more generality and there's a... and this is not meant in a nasty way, there's an arrogance that we all kind of carry. We've we've done some cool stuff, we've seen these results come in. We feel pretty bloody good. Then you go to conferences or you go to events and you speak to people and you say, 'hey, what do you do? ' 'I run an agency. ' What's the first question that someone asks you when you mention that you run an agency?
Will OckendenGood question. What clients have you got? How big is the agency?
Chris NortonYeah, how many people are you? Yeah, exactly, first question and then what's the business?
Chris SimmanceYeah, there's an assumption that number of staff equals some prestige. Everyone's measured up.
Chris NortonAnd going back to your numbers thing, the prestige and staff thing, right. So I was recently on some sort of workshop and I thought this was quite interesting because the guy that was running the workshop said,
Measuring Success, Evaluating New Business
Chris Nortonroughly to figure out your revenue per head, whatever business you're in, it's usually about 100,000 per head. I was like that can't be right, that's too simple. And he said it is a bit simplistic. But then I went okay, 100,000 per head. And we're in the PR sector, so I went on PR Week's top 150, and you can see PR revenue per head and it was between 85 and 150. So I was like that is about right for our sector?
Chris NortonI don't know what about for your sector.
Chris SimmanceAnd I mean for me in particular. I mean all my agency advisors are consultants for us, so I don't know what they charge, what they pay, what they get paid. But when I started the agency the original agency back in 2014, we worked on a rule of seven, so it was about seven grand a head per person, which then roughly was about 80/90 ish over the course of an entire year. So probably about the same as it was as a benchmark back then actually.
Chris NortonSo it does just kind of work, doesn't it?
Chris SimmanceT he thing, I think we often mistake is scale/ growth/ all this hustle nonsense that everyone talks about all the time.
Chris SimmanceAnd your business is as good as you measure it and as good as the bank balance can measure it. So you know, if you look at what you want from the business and it is 100 person team, you need to make sure that you can afford to live well enough and healthy enough to have 100 person team. And therefore you have numbers you need to make in order to do that. If you want to take 100,000, 200,000 pounds a month, a year of profit out of the business, clear profit for yourselves, you either need x revenue or wide net profit from the business and that's the measure of success. And so I often tell the agency leaders that I work with and quite a lot of the advisors that work with me often. As well as your success and your scale and your value and your bravado in your agency should be measured on where you are, against where you want to be going.
Chris NortonOkay, and Will had a question there.
Will OckendenYes, sorry. Just circling back to the new business conversation, the pitching for new business, a couple of kind of red flags we personally have a number of agencies invited to pitch and timeframes. You know, sometimes great brand, but you get quite an unrealistic timeframe. You know, sometimes it's a week, isn't it? Yeah, and it's clear you're a bit of an afterthought or there's misorganization on their side.
Will OckendenIs there any kind hard and fast? You know at what point would you refuse a brief? You know, with the number of agencies being invited to pitch, do you?
Chris NortonWe were about to pitch for a holiday brand, famous holiday brand, which we shall remain nameless, and they told us that we were one of 12. And we said no, thank you, goodbye. Which is astonishing, that a marketing director would have the time to consult 12 agencies, and they were shocked that we'd turned them down because they're a big, big, big, well known brand. But we we're just like, that's just a waste of time.
Chris SimmanceYeah, yeah. And so general rule of thumb gut level red flag for me was you scan to the bottom and you see
Setting Expectations and Growth Hacks
Chris Simmanceif there are fee expectations. So if they don't say how much they're looking for as fees, then the chances are they're buying on price and it doesn't really matter how good your pitch is. So probably walk away, because it's a race to the bottom essentially and bear in mind I'm saying all this with that with the comfort of sitting on the other side of the fence as I give this advice so you need to take all this with as much pinch of salt as you can.
Chris SimmanceAnd the other thing is, if you do have fees in there, scan through and see how many pages this RFP is and if it's like 20 or 30 pages and the fee doesn't feel right based on the fact that you've not even read those 20 or 30 pages, maybe their expectations are too high. And the vast majority of the reason why agencies lose their clients isn't usually because of results, unless you're a terrible agency. You usually lose clients because of the fact that you've not set expectations properly or they've not managed to set expectations properly and it's ultimately because we're people and we kind of assume that someone thinks the same way or whatever else. But if their expectations are 30 page RFP and the fees seem decent, but not like decent enough to be able to level expectation.
Chris SimmanceHow are you going to condense a 30 page RFP into a one hour presentation deck kind of thing. There's a mismatch immediately.
Chris NortonExpectations is you're right. That is exactly why agencies or you would fire a supplier, because at the end of the day, you're not going to be bad at your job. But if their expectations are set too high, you're right. And it's all down to the pitch as well, because some people to win a pitch, will promise the earth and we try to not do that. You have to try to not do that because if you do that at the pitch, you start on the back foot, which is always a nightmare.
Will OckendenAnd I think a lot of agencies, there's the tendency to go in cheap. You know win it on price, and that's great for three months isn't it, before the bitterness sets in and you realise you're making no money from it and then you can no longer put the price up.
Chris NortonThe three month bitterness. We don't get that. We don't get that.
Chris SimmanceAnd the three month bitterness sets in, just around the time that sadly, another client leaves or you have to pay a recruiter 20% fees to replace a member of staff that left because of internal expectation management as well.
Chris NortonI don't know if we did, did we get your biggest fuck up? We got to the VAT, but we never got to the bottom of your biggest professional fuck up. We need to get that into the show.
Will OckendenToo emotional I think it was. You're too emotional.
Chris SimmanceI take too much mental ownership of stuff and then therefore, it feels bad when something goes wrong. So emotionally dealing with things is probably the biggest fuck up, because I think there were some great people who worked with me years ago and I am 90% certain that almost all of them desperately dislike me and that's why. So it was a fuck up, because I did it wrong.
Will OckendenAnd how did this?
Chris SimmanceNo, I think I'm far too passive aggressive and I'm very good with my words, should we say, wasn't swearing and all that sort of stuff, but I just wasn't very nice at talking to people and it's not a nice way to treat people who choose to work with you.
Chris NortonNo, and they won't stay with you. And this is the thing I worked for somebody a long time ago before I set up, and then I saw him. I came into a meeting and he was briefing his graphics team and he shouting and screaming at somebody who'd fucked up a design, one of the designers, and he kicked all these leaflets over.
Chris NortonDo you remember the good old days of leaflets? We used to design and brand it. He kicked all the leaflets over and Effing and Jeffing and I just thought I never want to behave like this. It was shocking behavior and to see people that it doesn't get the best out of people if they live in fear, does it?
Chris SimmanceIt doesn't, and I read a lot and I've learned a lot since and I've realized that there's a quote and I'm not going to remember who it's from, but it's never a tribute to Malistak that could be attributed to ignorance, and usually that ignorance is because you haven't briefed someone properly or you haven't given them the training they need or you haven't given them the time that they need to deliver it properly. It's very rarely is it the person being maliciously negligent in any way.
Chris NortonI was going to ask about, if you don't mind Will, what's your top hack for growth then?
Chris SimmanceKnow where you're going, have a plan. I know it sounds very arbitrary, but if you know where you're going, let's say you have a three year vision, for in three years we're going to be in this place. That's something you can articulate to your team. That's something you can create messaging around, that's something which you can create OKRs around, that's something that people will work towards. It's also something that helps you if you've got a long horizon, a long view. When something doesn't go to plan, you know whether or not it's going to impact that vision and you can keep the people on track.
Chris SimmanceThere's essentially four stages in making changes in the business. You've got the forming, the storming, the norming, then
The Importance of Leadership in Business
Chris Simmancethe performing stage. At the forming stage, you've come up with your vision and you come up with your idea and you tell everyone how cool it is and everyone's like, yeah, this is great and we're going to do this cool stuff. Then you get into the storming stage and that's where everything's changing a little bit and people forget who they are and what they're doing and things go wrong and people shout and it doesn't feel very nice and usually most agencies will go straight back to the forming bit because it doesn't feel very nice. It doesn't feel very comfortable and they'll have spent a load of money, time and effort and lost a few clients and lost a few things, rather than kind of sitting in that discomfort and work out how to get it right and how to tweak it a little bit before you then get into this norming stage where things are running well and things are running in an even keel.
Chris SimmanceI know what my job is, they know what their job is, everyone's reporting things properly, and then you can start performing. But most agencies think they're growing, but they're going forming, storming, forming, storming, forming, storming, forming. And if you can get out of that, then you start like literally growing, and the first way you do it is you know where you're going at the end.
Will OckendenSomething we talked about in the pre-show notes was this kind of idea of the difference between management and leadership and that painting that vision and taking people on that journey that's leadership, isn't it? It's very different to management, and what are the mistakes? Something you said to me which stuck with me management is learned, leadership is earned. Can you tell us a bit about that? What do you mean by that?
Chris SimmanceSo I mean typically, almost anyone who has enough experience in a role or in an industry can be a manager. There's obviously nuanced layers to that because of the personal preferences and all sorts of things like that, but almost everyone could learn to be a manager because in management there's an empathetic layer on top of processes. This is how you deliver delegation. This is how you manage feedback. This is how you keep things on track. This is how you deal with this, whereas leadership is a huge amount more personal ownership and accountability.
Chris SimmanceLeadership is. There's a lot more consistency required. You need to really know who you are before you can lead, and most people will never get to that point and it's not because they're not good people, it's because we're just running a million miles an hour. Who has the time to decide those quite important things? You can lead people as an owner of a business.
Chris SimmanceYou can lead things, but a leader is someone who genuinely gets followers, who have people follow them, because they want to go where that person's going and they want to be where that company or that group of people are going, and that's the difference. You have to earn that, because people have to trust you, they have to understand you. You have to understand them. You have to be able to very clearly and cogently articulate like where you want to be. And if you can't articulate that properly in a way that people who are employed by a business, who choose to have the roles that they do, if you can't articulate internally the thing that is meaningful to a junior exec who you want to stay in the business for five years, what five years looks like to them, then you can't necessarily expect to lead them that way for five years. So it's a big difference.
Chris NortonYou're right, you get good at something. So I was good at public relations, started an agency and then I've had to learn how to become a leader. We share books. You have to learn it, but you've said it's earned, but I do think you have to learn leadership as well. Because you can lead sort of at the beginning, when everyone's friends and mates and there's only three or four of you.
Chris NortonAnd you're sort of learning how to manage and how to lead something. But when you get to above 15 people and you have to be a leader, otherwise. Like, COVID made a lot of people leaders, I have to say. You had to lead through that period because those few days where we lost 90% of revenue in 24 hours.
Chris NortonAnd you know everybody was pausing. Everybody went through it. All agency owners, if they're listening to this, will have been through that and that period really made you earn your leadership, I think.
Chris SimmanceYeah, and there's a distinction I guess, between you as the leader earning it because you've done something hard, and the team believing that you've earned it because they've seen that the vision is still being realised and that you are someone they want to follow. So I can earn leadership by being a leader, but the people that decide that I'm a leader are the people that follow me, and if they don't, then I'm not one yet.
Chris NortonOK. So I'm going to check out how many followers you've got now and if we are following you. If you want to follow Chris on Twitter, I'll give you a plug for your Twitter. Is it Twitter. com slash Chris Simmons? That's right, isn't it?
Chris SimmanceYes, that's it. That's it, all one word.
Chris NortonAnd what's your website? Where can people find you?
Chris SimmanceIt's X. com soon, isn't it? It's X. com soon, isn't it?
Chris SimmanceSo if you want to find out a bit more about the OMG accelerator program, then you can go to omg. center. com/ info center spell the American way, and then you'll find all the links that you need to take you to where you want to go.
Chris NortonYeah, thanks - really fascinating chat, Chris. Thanks for coming on the show, and the best bit about this interview is the Batman sign and the Pac-Man signs behind your head. I think I can't take my eyes off of it. Is that just your bedroom or is that a studio?
Chris SimmanceNo, this is the studio in the office here. So when you guys asked at the beginning about podcasts and quality and things like that, one of the things that I spent ages doing was YouTube videos on how to get podcast setups right. So I've got hue lights here, elgato lights there, I've got all these, all this paraphernalia to stop noise bouncing off of hard walls and things like that.
Chris NortonSo these here on the wall. You see, these are all soundproofers.
Will OckendenSo yeah, but they're just in our boardroom because it was quite echoey. Otherwise, it sounds like you're talking in a toilet cubicle or something.
Chris NortonYeah, it was really rattly when we first moved in this building.
Will OckendenAnd do you have an office dog, Chris?
Chris NortonYeah, where is the office dog? I do, I have two, that's actually Stephen.
Chris SimmanceHe's going to be nine this month and we've got Luna, who's his assistant office dog. She's a rescue and she speaks too much, so I can't have her in the room when I record.
Chris NortonOK.
Chris SimmanceYeah.
Will OckendenSo any kind of concluding thoughts before we wrap things up, Chris?
Chris SimmanceAnd I think to one of the points that I mainly talked about if you don't know your numbers and where
Insights on Agency Ownership and Growth
Chris Simmanceyou're going, know your numbers and know where you're going. And if you don't speak to people, speak to agency peers etc. Speak to advisors, speak to coaches, try and work out where you're going, because then you can articulate where you're going to your team. The other part is we talked about what all other agency leaders are like and how they all behave, and is it all pigheadedness and that sort of stuff? Well, you can find out because we're running an event in Manchester on the 19th of October. So if you go to omgcenter for IRL, then you'll find all the information about that. And if you really want to learn about leadership and management, get my book. It's on Amazon, it's on Kindle, it's on Audioball, so you know a few plugs there.
Chris NortonSo I'm adding this to the podcast from now on. This is my final question. In your opinion, who should be the next guest on our podcast, and what do you think we should
Chris SimmanceSo I think you should have Jerry White on the podcast next. I don't know if you know Jerry White. He's been in the industry since before it was called an industry, I think. He's worked in-house, he's worked in agencies, he's worked for brands, he's worked software companies - all in the search and data aspect of things. What he doesn't have in terms of perspective on this industry, isn't worth having if that's the case.
Chris NortonNice, all right, thank you for that.
Will OckendenOK great.
Chris NortonThanks for that Chris.
Chris SimmanceNo problem. T hank you very much for having me on.
Will OckendenSo that was a bit different, wasn't it, Chris? Normally we speak with brands, but actually getting a perspective from agency ownership and agency growth was fascinating.
Chris NortonYeah, his take. Well, I've listened to two or three of his podcasts with agency owners and all very different people. Some people I know on Twitter, like Daryl, and then some other guys that are working in different sectors. And obviously dealing with agency owners, like I said in the interview I know probably eight or nine and you know a few as well and is there a commonality between them? Are they all like us? I don't know?
Will OckendenWell, I think there's the cliched agency owner, isn't there? Who's you know, we've all watched Mad Men. I think that informs a lot of actually different personalities, introverts and extroverts. But yeah, undoubtedly it's a fast moving, competitive, creative industry, so you're bound to get certain personality types entering that profession.
Chris NortonLike you said, he sees a lot of arrogance. I was like 'oh god, I hope we don't come across like that'. But he said because of the industry people winning awards, you're doing great work and you're like, actually yeah, we can do great. To start a business, you've got to think I can do a great. I suppose there has to be a certain type of person, but that bit was quite interesting. I also wanted to really delve onto his fuckups but, as Tyler just said to me in the off break there, it felt like a bit of a therapy session for his former staff. I mean, we've all made mistakes running a business, but obviously he's then used that to become a mentor and business advisor, which is quite a different take to have run two or three different agencies and then become a coach. That could add real value. If you're an agency owner, I suppose, and you want to coach.
Will OckendenYeh, and a couple of points there. First of all, I think the competitive nature of our industry must drive this. I mean not every industry. You go head to head every pitch with four or five other agencies and that's bound to lead to a certain kind of emotional response to how you behave. And the other point I found interesting, which I would say is an issue in the industry when people start agencies, they're great at their job, they're creative, they know how to do the job, but it's actually the on the business side of things that perhaps people don't know; leadership, HR, finance.
Will OckendenAnd a lot of that, you learn on the job, which is crazy when you think about it. You know you need and we're big believers in training and skills and development aren't we at Prohibition? You need training. You need to understand the basics and the fundamentals.
Chris NortonYeah, but maybe he's got to a point there like where the arrogance. So like you and I both go to conferences now or speak at some, which is fine, you know you get to invite to speak at some CIPR or whatever, but I go down to the PR week one to hear what other people have got to say. Because as soon as you become an agency owner, you need to learn to adapt, innovate and stay on top of what everybody else is thinking, because what you're thinking now is not necessarily what everybody's going to be thinking in five years. You've got to stay on top of innovation and you've got to become, dare I say it as a business owner, some days you've got to be a bit of a counselor. You know helping people through difficult times. There's all sorts of different things and you have to learn that like you say on the job. But leadership courses do help with that.
Will OckendenYeah, absolutely, and I think you mentioned kind of chatting with other agency owners. I think it does often end up as a bit of a therapy session.
Chris NortonYeah.
Will OckendenAnd often you think you're the only person going through this but actually you speak to other agency owners and I think it's fairly unique to the agency landscape, isn't it? Like Chris said, you know it's very, very competitive, it's very, very creative and that creates a unique set of a unique set of problems in a lot of cases.
Chris NortonWell yeah, because you when I was down at the PR week conference and we were talking to a . And of the owners down there and they were telling me because obviously we're in Leeds in the north of the UK, we're not in London, but we do serve clients all around the UK. But their take is, 'oh my god, staff retention in London is a nightmare'. Unless you're one of the big five agencies in London, you know there's hundreds, isn't there and just keeping staff for more than a year, recruitment fees to replace those jobs. I was just like, oh my. I said we do quite well, touch wood in terms of that. We've got some great competitors locally in Yorkshire that we have.
Chris NortonYou know that's fine, it's good to have competition. But in terms of, you know, we've got quite good retention rates, whereas that's not a massive issue for us. But I did feel sorry for them. So, yeah, you're right, it is a bit of a therapy session hearing what you know, because obviously clients just want you to do great work, what campaigns can you do. They don't want to hear about all the agency staff retention. You know all the things that Chris talked about.
Will OckendenWhat goes on behind the curtain, isn't it? Absolutely.
Chris NortonWe haven't got any curtains. Right, well yeah. So a big thank you to Chris for coming on the show. A couple of plugs we have got. If you're interested in what we do, we have got a 15 minute discovery session that Will always talks about. You can find that if you want to book a 15 minute discovery session with us, just go to https://bit. ly/sociallyUA that's for guests and listeners of this show. And also if you'd like what you've heard in these podcasts, we also do webinars, which are longer and obviously face to face, live webinars. Our next one's on influencer marketing, all you have to do is go to prohibition. pr. co. uk that's prohibition. pr. co. uk and click on events and you'll find our list of events. We've got about 10 on demand events and tons coming up, including one on AI, which will be fascinating. And obviously, subscribe to the YouTube channel and keep listening, because we we thank you, each and every one of you, for listening. I hope you found today interesting and we will see you in a couple of weeks. Thank you.
Vicki MurphyThank you for listening to socially unacceptable. Please remember to subscribe to the podcast and leave us a five star review. Don't forget to follow us on social media on Twitter and Instagram at ProhibitionPR, we would love to hear some of your career fuck ups so we can share them on the show. For more information on the show, search ProhibitionPR in your search engine and click on podcasts. Until next time, please keep pushing the boundaries and embracing the socially unacceptable.