Embracing Marketing Mistakes
Welcome to Embracing Marketing Mistakes, the world’s leading irreverent podcast for senior marketers who are tired of the polished corporate b*llshit.
Join Chris Norton and Will Ockenden, founders of the award-winning Prohibition PR, as they sit down with industry leaders to dissect the career-ending f*ck-ups they’d rather forget. The show moves past any pretty vanity metrics to uncover the brutal, honest truths behind marketing disasters, from £30,000 SEO black holes and completely failed companies, to social media crises that went globally viral for all the wrong reasons.
We don't just celebrate the f*ck-ups; we extract the tactical blueprints you need to avoid them yourself. If you are a business owner, or a CMO looking for a competitive advantage that only comes from real-world experience, this is your weekly masterclass in resilience and strategy.
- Listen for: Raw stories from top brands, ex-McKinsey strategists, and industry disruptors.
- Learn from: The errors that cost thousands and the recoveries that saved careers.
- Get ahead by: Turning other people's nasty disasters into your unfair market advantage.
If you have a story to tell and would like to appear on the show, tell us your biggest marketing mistake and drop us a line.
Embracing Marketing Mistakes
What Can We Learn from Olaplex's Battle Against Imitators?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Ever wonder how a brand can elegantly dance around the issue of product knock-offs while reinforcing its market dominance? Sinead Morrissey from Prohibition joins us to reveal how Olaplex's 'Ola Dupe' campaign did just that—turning the tide of imitation into a wave of authentic brand love. Sinead, who rose through the ranks from intern to senior account manager, shares her first-hand experience of this marketing masterstroke. Together, we unwrap how Olaplex sent fake duplicates to influencers, setting the stage for a grand reveal that showcased the unmatched value of their patented haircare formula. This innovative approach not only combated counterfeit culture but also amplified Olaplex's prestige in the beauty industry.
We're have a candid conversation about the art of keeping things straightforward yet profoundly impactful in creative campaigns. Sinead captivates us with a story of a slight PR blunder, reminding us that we're all human—even the pros. Don't miss this episode of Campaign Crunch, where we explore the brilliance behind Olaplex's fight against fakes and celebrate the delightful mishaps that keep the world of PR spinning.
Is your strategy still right in 2026? Book a free 15-min no obligation discovery call with our host: 👉 [Book your call with Chris now] 👈
Subscribe to our newsletter
👉 Subscribe to our newsletter here. 👈
Follow Chris:
X, TikTok, LinkedIn
Follow Will:
LinkedIn
Follow The Show:
TikTok, YouTube
Welcome to Campaign Crunch, our concise companion to Socially Inacceptable. This is a much shorter version of the show and we delve into the best marketing campaigns, dissecting successes, missteps and everything in between, all in under 20 minutes. Each episode tackles a specific campaign or crisis, meticulously examining its strategy, execution and, most importantly, the key takeaways for you and your brand. Hi everybody, welcome back to Campaign Crunch. This week we've got with us the lovely Sinead Morrissey. Welcome to the show. Sinead Hi, why don't you tell us a little bit about who you are and what you do for us at Prohibition? Okay, I'm Sinead Hi. Why don't you tell us a little bit about who you are and what you?
Speaker 2do for a position. Okay, I'm Sinead. As Chris said, I'm a senior account manager. I've been here for about six years. Yeah, I started as an intern. Met Chris when I was at uni.
Speaker 1Although that sounds weird, it sounds like I was sitting on your ear, does it yeah?
Speaker 3Chris was my.
Speaker 2Yeah, that sounds weird. It sounds like I was sitting on your ear.
Speaker 3That sounds creepy. Yeah, it does sound a bit groomy, creepy, groomy, groomy, groomy. That's worse. We'll leave that in.
Speaker 2So Chris was my lecturer and he groomed me to come and work at Prohibition. Thanks for that, and yeah. So I interned and then freelanced, and then you've not been able to get rid of me since.
Speaker 1That's it. So what are you here to talk about today, then? What campaign have you brought to us to illuminate the world of marketing about?
Speaker 2Well, I'm going to start slowly, because I don't think this is a world that either of you two are very familiar with. Premium hair care.
Speaker 1What are you saying Just for men?
Speaker 2Is it just for men and Donald Trump no so have either of you ever heard of Olaplex? Uh-huh.
Speaker 3What is it? It's a premium hair care product.
Speaker 2So, yeah, okay, olaplex, we'll do a bit of background on what that actually is. Okay, Premium hair care for professional, professional hairdressers so you could go and get like an in-salon treatment. Um, but then they also launched a consumer line so it's pretty expensive. Um, you're looking at like 50 60 quid for a shampoo and conditioner yeah, okay so they're like. Obviously, you're both familiar with dupe culture, right? This is probably one of the most duped products in the market.
Speaker 2So you might have to explain dupe culture to so dupes are basically when it tends to be like high street retailers will recreate a premium product at like half the price or even less. So Aldi does a lot of dupes. They actually do a dupe for Olaplex.
Speaker 1Colin the Caterpillar type stuff when they copied M&S.
Speaker 2Yeah, but just tends to be a lot cheaper. They claim it's as good as the original. Some of them are, some of them aren't.
Speaker 3I'm right in saying that it's completely different formulations. Is it when Aldi will dupe something, or is it sometimes a case of literally same production line, different branding?
Speaker 2If they can do, yeah, but obviously this product in particular has 160 different patterns, is that how you say it?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So that's like impossible to duplicate. So no dupe of olaplex is ever going to be as good as the original, so interesting.
Speaker 3In terms of brand equity, it's super strong yeah, okay.
Speaker 2So pre this campaign that we're going to talk about, which is the ola dupe campaign, um, tiktok creators had posted so much content around Olaplex dupes on TikTok and social media. There was 30.4 million views of the hashtag pre-campaign, and that's the hashtag Olaplex dupe. Olaplex obviously was sick and tired of being replicated and then, using their social listening tools, they identified how often it was being duped and, in retaliation, launched Ola Dupe to show consumers that they're the only company that can actually dupe Olaplex. So basically, what they did is they sent out 100 Ola Dupe press boxes to influencers. Um, the packaging was like pretty much identical, um, and it was that all of their products are kind of given numbers, so there's like number three, which is like a bond, something or other. They all do different things, um, and they called this ola dupe number 160, which is a nod to the 160 patents in the product that we're keeping up yeah, can I just stop you there have they created a man's version which is called ola tupe tupe?
Speaker 1premium hair products. Okay, moving on. Okay, I had to get that joke in there because I thought, oh, that's a good one, it rhymes.
Speaker 2So yeah, so they basically created this product, sent it out to over 100 influencers and launched an unboxing campaign which took place on TikTok and Instagram. Then, basically, the call to action for consumers was that there was 160 free bottles of Oladupe which were available on the website, which was actually like one of their other products. That people got sent along with an explanation of the stunt, but it was quite clever because they worked with an influencer I think she's called Taylor Madison and she's like a celebrity dupe because she looks like Kylie Jenner. So they sent the celebrity dupe the dupe product.
Speaker 3Multi-layered this campaign? Yeah, it's really well thought through, but it's quite confusing. It's multi-layered this campaign.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's really well thought through but it's quite confusing. So they basically did lots of different videos with influencers, so a lot of them unboxed it and then, as like a follow-up, they did a video revealing. They basically peeled the sticker the Oladipay sticker off and it revealed that it was actually Olaplex underneath. Then, as if that wasn't confusing enough, um, they basically the ceo at the time, julie wong, I think she was called um released a video basically talking people through the dupe and why they did it. But actually it was a deep fake video. So they really committed to deep culture here and and basically she like she just basically then appeared in her actual form on the video and was like, oh, that wasn't really me like basically just tricking people, um, but essentially oladip hashtag. Oladipay had 49 million views on TikTok. Every free bottle was claimed within two hours and the marketing stunt generated 1.1 million in global earned media value.
Speaker 3And have they reclaimed their narrative?
Speaker 2then yeah, 100% no. Like they've just proved that it is pretty much impossible to dupe them.
Speaker 1What I like about this is that it was a they made. The product that they gave away was the 160, and it's because of the 160 patents, isn't it's? That is the whole thing is really cleverly thought through, yeah, for me they've.
Speaker 3They've really understood social media, haven't they? And I think that you know big brands. Often the tendency would be like right, we need some lawsuits here we need to sue the hell out of everybody duping. Actually, they, they've recognized that conversation is not going to change, so let's become part of that conversation. And they've they've really understood how tiktok works. And how to how to kind of shift that conversation, haven't they?
Speaker 1and it was perfect for their audience there's a quote there as well, isn't there? While in imitation is the highest form of flattery. We wanted to have fun with the fact that the opel how do you say it? Olaplex.
Speaker 2We wanted to have fun with the fact that the Ople how do you say it? Olaplex.
Speaker 3We wanted to have fun that the Olaplex you say brand, but you pronounce that word brand. Is that what it is?
Speaker 1Do you want me to read it? Yeah, you read it. We'll just edit me out.
Speaker 2Well, imitation is the highest form of flattery. We wanted to have fun with the fact that the Olaplex brand can be imitated but never replicated, and that was from the CMO.
Speaker 3That's brilliant and for me, it's quite a brave, bold campaign and I think the word fun there is quite interesting because they have had fun with it haven't they. And it is a fun campaign. It's really got some good results. The fact that this deepfake CEO statement as well is just kind of multi-layered it's like I'm peeling an onion isn't it?
Speaker 2It's tapping into every layer of social media and all of the scary things that are out there, basically.
Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely. What a great campaign. And I think the product is obviously. I mean, it's the fact that it can't be copied, it's a very high price point, it's got some real kind of value and that's probably that probably explains the kind of the frenzy to get these hands on the free products have you used the product?
Speaker 1that's the question. I have yes, and what do you think? Um is it worth the money?
Speaker 2I haven't used the shampoo and conditioner. I've used, like, the pre-hair wash treatment and it is good. But even that was like, I think, £35, £40.
Speaker 3Is this? Is this like?
Speaker 1Hang on Pre-hair wash. Yeah, so you put it on, you wash your hair before you wash your hair.
Speaker 2Well, it's like a hair mask and like obviously the range is so much more than just shampoo and conditioner. There's all sorts A hair mask.
Speaker 3Zach uses a hair mask, don't you?
Speaker 1He wears a hat.
Speaker 3He's got a hat mask, so is this a bit like the GHD strategy and the kind of. I think was it the early noughties when they obviously they launched GHD. It was only available through salons. It was, you know, 150 quid at the time, which now probably doesn't seem like all that much, and it was absolutely. I remember when I was at university and the kind of the it was an absolute phenomenon on ghd hair straighteners and because you could only buy them in salons.
Speaker 2They there's an element of scarcity about them as well yeah, I think obviously that's how they started um, and people even nowadays, like when you go to like the salon to get your hair done, people will add on olaplex treatments because they're not necessarily willing. I don't know how much it costs in hairdressers, um, but they might not be willing to spend the money themselves. But the ladder on it's like a bit of a treat as a bolt-on yeah, you have to pay for interesting interesting.
Speaker 3So, um, a lot of different sort of themes here, I think, um, and you know, from from a kind of a broader perspective though, so our listeners will be listening to this, thinking, wow, okay, that's, that's quite a bold campaign. What are the kind of the lessons or the learnings do you think that other other brands can take from this?
Importance of Simple, Effective Creativity
Speaker 2I think probably to be brave. Um, but it's, it's. It's quite simple, like in it's. When you look at what they actually did, it's very simple and probably if you came up with the idea, people might just think that's not going to work like it's.
Speaker 3It's kind of obvious obvious, but the best creative ideas are simple. If you need to explain a creative idea more than a sentence, it's not a good idea.
Speaker 2Yeah, they've just they executed it very well and they've just they obviously know their audience so so well, because I am their audience and even like all those followers that all those influencers that they worked with were just perfect, like even down to using like the celebrity duper, but yeah, I think it was just really well thought through and they've actually managed to insert themselves in the middle of the conversation and like the cultural phenomenon that dupe culture is Rather than fighting against it they've gone with the momentum of that conversation and now they're leading it, aren't they?
Speaker 3Sort of?
Speaker 1taking the M&S approach and suing the shit out of Aldi, allegedly close brackets.
Sinead's F*ck Up
Speaker 3Allegedly Final point for me, I think, the importance of understanding and listening to how your brand's talked about and understanding what those narratives are, rather than just kind of burying your head in the sand if there's negatives or positives or conversations you don't like, and they've absolutely done that and they absolutely understand the channels as well, don't they yeah. Yeah, good, thank you for that.
Speaker 1Right, well, Sinead. Another question that we ask all our guests on the show is about the professional fuck-up that they're deeply, deeply proud of, and in the pre-show briefing.
Speaker 2Sinead claimed she's never fucked up in her years of being a PR professional. Hence why we've never either, I haven't. This is a really tough one for me.
Speaker 1You can't think of any mistake you've ever made.
Speaker 2I don't make mistakes. Is that like?
Speaker 3saying my biggest flaw is that I'm a perfectionist in a job interview.
Speaker 2I probably said that. No, I'm sure there's many.
Speaker 1A few moments later.
Speaker 2I mean only like small stuff, probably Like I did once send an invite out to a pizza storm event without the date or the time on it. That's about it what? Happened to the restaurant and chain pizza storm and they went bust shortly after.
Speaker 3And we're not for a moment linking the two no, absolutely not right, sinead. Thank you very much for that. That was illuminating and interesting and, um yeah, food for thought for all of us.