Embracing Marketing Mistakes
Embracing Marketing Mistakes is the show that teaches you growth from failure.
Every week, the Founder of Prohibition PR, Chris Norton and his co-host, Will Ockenden, sit down with the people behind some of marketing's best-known brands and ask the question most interviews avoid: what went wrong, and what did you do next?
Rand Fishkin, Richard Shotton, Ben Branson, Phil Barden and Roger Dooley have all owned up. So have marketers from Yorkshire Tea, Lexus, Adobe, Deliveroo and Ogilvy.
You hear about the campaigns that flopped and the calls they got wrong, told honestly and with a sense of humour. Then you get the lesson, so you can skip the expensive part.
A top 10 UK marketing podcast on Apple, with 135+ interviews and 550,000 downloads across 172 countries. New episode every week.
If you have a story to tell and would like to appear on the show, tell us your biggest marketing mistake and drop us a line.
Embracing Marketing Mistakes
What happens when creativity outpaces strategy?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of Embracing Marketing Mistakes, I’m joined by Gareth Turner, founder of Big Black Door and former Head of Marketing at Weetabix. Gareth has over 23 years of experience in food and drink, having led marketing for brands like John Smith’s, Bulmers, Lurpak and Arla. From buying a racehorse for John Smith’s to launching Bulmers fruit ciders and leading the viral Beanz on Bix campaign, his career is packed with bold ideas and brilliant lessons.
Gareth opens up about one of his biggest missteps: a bizarre PR stunt involving a coat made of human hair to promote a chocolate milkshake. The idea aimed to poke fun at over-the-top masculinity in advertising but fell flat due to a lack of strategic grounding and a weak link to the product.
• Created a coat from barbershop hair to promote protein chocolate milk
• Concept satirised extreme masculinity in ads
• Missed the mark with an unclear product connection
• Broke a key food marketing rule by undermining appetite appeal
• Gained international attention, including CNN Japan
• Might spark social media buzz today, but still fails on brand relevance
Do you have a F*ck up to share?
Your competitors are being named by AI. Are you? One of our clients went from being named in 4 of 50 buyer prompts to 19 in 90 days. Book your free AI visibility check with Chris here. 👉 [Book free AI Visibility Check] 👈
Subscribe to our newsletter
The mistakes we see marketers make, every fortnight. 👉 [Subscribe here] 👈
Follow Chris:
X, TikTok, LinkedIn
Follow Will:
LinkedIn
Follow The Show:
TikTok, YouTube
Setting up the marketing mishap
Will OckendenSo do you want to tell us about some of the campaigns that haven't perhaps worked as well ?
Gareth TurnerYou want to go there , do you ? We do , we do ? Oh , definitely , straight in there . So I left Heineken and I joined Arla and I wanted to make a name for myself . So I was tasked with launching this chocolate milkshake drink and I launched this chocolate milkshake drink . We had a campaign shot . We had uh , outdoor and I need the pr , need the pr campaign here , right and okay , it sticks in my throat , you can see . You see me hesitating to even say it right sticking there .
Chris NortonI can't bring myself . This is why everyone's you want to hear this .
Gareth TurnerSo it
The human hair coat campaign
Gareth Turnerwas . The stunt was that we created a coat made out of human hair , made out of the sort of sweepings off a barbershop floor , and we got some London fashion students to make this thing and we PR'd that , I repeat , to support the launch of a chocolate milkshake .
Chris NortonSo okay , okay , let's just go back . We'll just wind back to the strategy .
Will OckendenWell , yeah , there you go . It's all based on insight .
Chris NortonSo the insight of having human hair onto a coat . Let's just go through the insight .
Gareth TurnerAnd there you go . There's the challenge , right . So the brand was it was a high-protein chocolate milk stream with added protein 25 grams of protein . It was an amazing product . And the campaign idea we were riffing on these ideas of overblown masculinity . So on my Facebook feed today the shoot was 11 years ago today and there's pictures of me . I can say I've never looked cooler than the moment of me in this coat and sort
Analyzing why it failed
Gareth Turnerof big , long fur coat .
Chris NortonCan we get that picture ?
Gareth TurnerIt wasn't in that coat .
Chris Nortongood Lord Is that picture on the internet . It's not the hair coat . We're going to get that in the video . Oh the hair coat .
Gareth TurnerI've given you a link to the hair coat .
Chris NortonOh , let's take a look at that .
Gareth TurnerBut it's overblown . Masculinity was the idea , and we had a guy holding a lion looking strong , like they're sort of perfume ads and sort of there's a riff on those sort of things , right , and it's like things like , yeah , we thought that was funny and so we just took it to the next level . So what could be more manly than a coat made of man hair ? And so that was the thought progression . But I come back to your point there was no insight there . So why did that not work ? Well , I think a number of different reasons . I think it was overly complicated . It was so many layers to that onion that you had to unpick to understand why we'd done that thing .
Gareth TurnerIt wasn't executing an idea , it was a thing that we thought was funny and I've since learned that's not probably good enough to uh , to , to to put out in the real , real world . And finally , a fundamental of marketing is if you're talking about a food , it needs to be talking about taste , or at least not going against taste , and it's not undermining taste credentials . So you put all those things together I I didn't adhere to the fundamentals of marketing and that's why that thing hence the name of the show that you've given us .
Will OckendenYeah
CNN Japan calls about the coat
Will Ockendenyeah , so , yeah that . So how has it met ? So you know you , you used this as a as a PR hook did you so what ? Was it met with indifference or confusion , or no , no , it was .
Chris NortonWhat was the title ? That was my question , similar to what we were saying what was the title of the release ?
Gareth TurnerI can't remember . I'm trying to connect the two dots like human hair . I'm just looking here . The news article from 2013 was Manly Milk Company Creates Human Hair Fur Coat .
Will OckendenThat's a very functional headline , isn't it ? But there was like a guy in this hair coat .
Gareth TurnerBut it got some traction .
Will OckendenSo it worked then ? Well , not .
Gareth TurnerBut it's so complicated . You're right about the link . It was discussed .
Will OckendenThe moment you've got to explain an idea . It's too complicated .
Gareth TurnerSo I'm there the first , however many months six , seven months I'm into my job at Arla and I get a call from the global head of PR . He goes Gareth , I've got CNN from Japan on the line . I go oh my God , what have I done ? What have I done ? I'm just trying to do good stuff here . And he goes yeah , don't worry , mate , I'll sort this out . They want an interview , cnn want an interview with you . Okay , I can't do this , but yeah , so despite that , I did .
Chris NortonAll right , did you go on it .
Gareth TurnerNo , no , no , no , no , no . Oh okay , no , no no . That was , I wasn't experienced enough to do that . Live Okay , life okay . Yeah , that it was . Yeah , it was . Thank god pierce morgan didn't get hold of that one , that would have been .
Chris NortonYeah , he wouldn't have liked . The weird thing , the weird thing about this is you're saying that he did get some traction despite the the headline being quite functional
Modern perspective on the campaign
Chris Norton. But actually if , in the modern era of social media and tiktok , if you're doing a tiktok video about the campaign , yeah creating a jacket out of human hair , although I have to admit it does sound revolting , doesn't ?
Will Ockendenit , it , it sounds itchy . It doesn't sound like something I want to wear .
Gareth TurnerIt was awful , but it doesn't link to the product . It doesn't link to the logic flow from your product and your product benefit of it's got high protein . I mean that's quite a leap there . So I mean that's why I didn't .